


Ask the community...
Just a thought - have you checked if your May certifications might be visible on your payment history page but just not processed yet? Sometimes they show up there in a "pending" status even when reps say they don't exist. The NYSDOL website is so poorly designed that different screens show different information. Also, did they give you any specific reason WHY the May claim "doesn't exist anymore"? Did someone cancel it? Did it expire? Was it rejected for some reason? Without an actual explanation, they're just giving you the runaround, and you deserve better than that!
I checked the payment history page and there's absolutely nothing for May there - not even pending status. The rep couldn't (or wouldn't) give me any specific reason why the claim doesn't exist. She just kept saying there's no record of it in her system and that I should "send a message through the portal." When I told her about my previous conversation with another rep who confirmed it existed, she just said "well I don't see anything here" and basically dismissed me. It was incredibly frustrating!
Based on all the information in this thread, it sounds like you're dealing with a system error rather than an eligibility issue. Your best course of action is to: 1. Try to reach a Tier 2 specialist who can access the audit log as mentioned 2. Submit the TC-403.1 form as formal documentation of the issue 3. Continue weekly certifications even for past weeks if the system allows it 4. Request a formal determination letter that you can appeal if necessary The good news is that if you're entitled to these benefits, you will eventually receive them - including back pay for May. The bad news is that it may take persistent effort on your part. Don't give up! Document every contact attempt, follow up regularly, and be prepared to appeal if necessary.
did u try calling from a different phone? my friend said sometimes ur number gets flagged as spam if u call too many times and they auto-reject it. tried from my mom's phone and got thru after like 30 tries instead of never
Just wanted to check in - were you able to get this resolved? If you're still having trouble, make sure you're using the right number: 1-888-209-8124 for regular UI claims. Also, once you do get through, ask them to put a note on your account about the payment delay so there's a record of your attempt to resolve it.
I actually got through yesterday! Used my assembly person's office like someone suggested AND tried calling from a different phone. Finally reached someone who told me there was an "account review flag" on my claim that nobody bothered to tell me about! They said payments should resume within 72 hours. I'm cautiously optimistic but won't believe it until I see the money. Thanks everyone for the help - this forum was more useful than the actual DOL website!
Back in 2023 I never got my 1099-G in the mail for some reason but it was in my online account the whole time! Check there first. Also make sure you're looking in the right section - it's not super obvious where they put it. Go to Unemployment Services and look for "1099-G Tax Forms" in the menu. Took me forever to find it the first time.
UPDATE: Mine just appeared in my online account! For anyone still waiting, definitely keep checking your NY.gov account. Under Unemployment Services there's a section specifically for tax forms. I never got an email notification that it was ready, just happened to check and it's there now. Thanks everyone for your help!
my brother just went thru this whole mess and it turned out the employer reported his wages for the wrong quarter which is what triggered the whole overpayment thing. make sure your friend checks what quarters they're claiming he was overpaid for and compare with his actual work history
One last important thing your friend should know: if the overpayment determination is upheld after fact-finding, he can still request a waiver of the overpayment if it would cause financial hardship AND the overpayment wasn't his fault. NY unemployment has become more lenient with these waivers since the 2025 policy updates. The waiver form asks for detailed financial information to demonstrate that repayment would cause significant hardship. Success rates for these waivers increased to about 65% this year, up from around 30% in previous years. Even if the overpayment is determined to be valid, there are still options available to him.
Miguel Silva
One thing no one mentioned - you should also file for SNAP benefits (food assistance) at the same time if your income has dropped significantly. Many people qualify during unemployment but don't realize it. The application can be done online through NY's myBenefits website and it's completely separate from unemployment.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•That's good to know, thanks. Hopefully won't be unemployed long enough to need it, but definitely worth keeping in mind depending how long the job search takes.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Make sure when you certify weekly you're answering EXACTLY correctly or they'll flag your account for review and freeze payments! Be hyper-literal with their questions. If you did ANY work, even an hour, report it. If you were 'unavailable' for work any day (like had a doctor's appointment) they count that too. The system is designed to catch people in tiny inconsistencies!
0 coins
NebulaNinja
•Thank you - I'll be super careful with the weekly certifications. Definitely don't want payments delayed over a misunderstanding.
0 coins