


Ask the community...
One thing to consider that nobody's mentioned yet - at your daughter's age, time is her biggest advantage. With a Roth (either IRA or 403b if they offer a Roth option), she'll never pay taxes on all that growth over 40+ years. That's potentially huge! When I was younger I focused solely on the traditional 401k for the immediate tax benefits, but now I wish I'd done more Roth contributions early in my career when my tax rate was lower. The math works out better in most cases for young people to pay the taxes now and enjoy tax-free growth forever.
Is there a calculator or something that shows the break-even point between traditional vs Roth? I always hear conflicting advice and don't know how to figure out which is actually better for my situation.
There's no perfect calculator because it depends on assumptions about future tax rates that nobody can predict with certainty. However, a good rule of thumb is that if you expect your tax rate in retirement to be higher than it is now, go with Roth. If you expect it to be lower, go traditional. For young people early in their careers with relatively low incomes, Roth often makes more sense because they're likely in a lower tax bracket now than they will be in retirement. But everyone's situation is different - factors like pension income, Social Security, and other retirement income sources can affect your future tax situation.
Has anyone considered suggesting a split approach? I contribute 5% to my traditional 403b to get the employer match, then max out my Roth IRA, then go back to the 403b if I can afford more. This gives me tax diversity in retirement.
Just another thing to consider - since this is referral income, you might have some actual business expenses to deduct on your Schedule C. Do you drive to any of these referral jobs? Do you use your personal phone? Do you have any marketing expenses or business cards? All of that could be deductible and lower your taxable income.
Thanks for mentioning this! I do actually use my personal phone to coordinate with the cleaning company about the referrals, and sometimes I drive to meet potential referral clients to assess their needs before connecting them. Would those miles be deductible? And what percentage of my phone bill could I reasonably claim?
Yes, the mileage for driving to meet potential referral clients would absolutely be deductible! Keep a log of those trips with dates, miles driven, and purpose. The current mileage rate for 2025 is 67 cents per mile, which adds up quickly. For your phone, you would deduct the percentage that you use for business purposes. If you use your phone about 30% of the time for these referrals, then you could deduct 30% of your bill. Just make sure you have a reasonable basis for whatever percentage you claim and keep your phone bills as documentation. You might also consider a separate phone line for business if the volume increases.
Just FYI since you're in Florida - I'm also in FL and did my own taxes for the first time last year with similar income. Your federal tax amount sounds right, but don't forget that interest income might still be subject to the Florida intangible tax depending on where the accounts are held. Most people don't realize this, but Florida still taxes certain intangible assets even though there's no state income tax. Worth double checking so you don't get a surprise letter later!
Florida repealed their intangible tax in 2007. There's no Florida state tax on interest income anymore. Been a Florida resident for 20+ years and a tax preparer for 15.
Thanks for the correction! I was confusing it with documentary stamp taxes on other financial instruments. That's why I should check my facts before posting. Good to know Florida residents truly don't have to worry about state taxes on interest income.
Have you thought about putting some of that savings into an IRA to lower your taxable income? I noticed your income would allow you to deduct traditional IRA contributions which could lower your tax bill. With over $13k in interest income, putting even $6k into an IRA would reduce your tax bill by around $1,320 if you're in the 22% bracket.
I hadn't considered that! Is it too late to do that for this tax year or can I still make a contribution that would count for this filing?
You're in luck! You can still make IRA contributions for the previous tax year until the tax filing deadline (usually April 15th). So you absolutely still have time to make a contribution and have it count for this filing. Just make sure when you make the contribution you specifically tell your financial institution it's for tax year 2024 (assuming that's the year you're filing for). They'll know how to code it properly. Then you can include that deduction in your tax return and it should reduce what you owe.
One thing nobody's mentioned yet - if you've been paying child support, that's not tax deductible for you, and it's not taxable income for your ex. It used to be that alimony was deductible for the payer and taxable for the recipient, but that changed with the tax law updates for divorces finalized after 2018. Also, if you're filing as married filing separately, be aware there are limitations on certain deductions and credits. You can't take the earned income credit, and the child tax credit can only be claimed by the parent who claims the child as a dependent. Student loan interest deductions are also not available when filing separately.
Thanks for pointing that out about the child support. I didn't think it was deductible but wasn't 100% sure. Do you know if there are any tax benefits I can still get even with the married filing separately status? I'm worried my tax bill is going to be much higher now.
While married filing separately does limit many tax benefits, you can still claim some deductions. You can take your portion of mortgage interest and property taxes if you itemize (though remember you can only deduct what you actually paid). You can still contribute to retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs, though income limits for deductible IRA contributions are much lower when filing separately. You might still qualify for the child and dependent care credit if you're the custodial parent, but the income limits are lower. And don't forget that you can still take your standard deduction - it's just half of what joint filers get. Your tax professional can run scenarios to see whether itemizing or taking the standard deduction benefits you more in your specific situation.
Don't forget about health insurance and medical expenses during divorce! If you covered your spouse and kids on your health insurance plan during the tax year, you can include premiums you paid for them in your medical expense deductions (if you itemize and your medical expenses exceed 7.5% of your AGI). Also, make sure you understand how the divorce affects your health insurance going forward. If your ex was covered under your employer plan, they'll need to get COBRA or find new insurance after the divorce. And make sure your divorce decree clearly specifies who will provide insurance for the children and how uncovered medical expenses will be divided.
Just want to add to this - if you're losing health insurance coverage because of divorce, that counts as a qualifying life event that lets you enroll in a marketplace plan outside of open enrollment. You have 60 days from when you lose coverage to enroll. Don't wait until the divorce is final if your coverage will end before then!
You definitely want to include specific language about how uncovered medical expenses will be split (like 50/50 or proportional to income). Make sure it clearly defines what counts as a medical expense - does it include just doctor visits and prescriptions, or also dental, vision, therapy, and orthodontics? Also include details about who needs to approve non-emergency medical treatments, how information about health issues will be shared between parents, and how reimbursement will work (timeframes for providing receipts and making payments). The more specific you can make these provisions, the fewer conflicts you'll have later. And remember that medical expense arrangements for the children can be modified in the future if circumstances change significantly.
Chloe Davis
Some states don't have income tax at all, so you might not need to file depending on where you live. For example, I'm in Florida and we don't have state income tax, so I don't file a state return even though I have similar 1099 forms from investments. The states with no income tax are: Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming. New Hampshire only taxes interest and dividend income.
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
ā¢I'm in Illinois, which definitely has state income tax unfortunately. So based on what everyone's saying, it sounds like I do need to file a state return even though all my income is from investments. Do you know if there's a minimum threshold for filing in states that do have income tax? Like if my investment income is pretty small, maybe I don't need to file?
0 coins
Chloe Davis
ā¢Illinois definitely requires filing for investment income. Their threshold is pretty low too - I believe it's only $2,275 for single filers in 2024. If your total income from all sources (including those 1099 forms) exceeds that amount, you need to file. Even with relatively small investment income, you should still file. One benefit is that Illinois has a property tax credit that you might be eligible for, so you could actually get money back depending on your situation. Many people miss out on state tax credits because they incorrectly assume they don't need to file.
0 coins
AstroAlpha
Probably a stupid question but how do investment apps even know which state to report your income to? I use Robinhood and Webull just like you and moved twice last year...
0 coins
Diego Chavez
ā¢Not a stupid question! Investment companies report your info to the IRS with your SSN but don't actually determine which state you file in. They typically send 1099s with your federal info only. It's your responsibility to report that income on the correct state returns based on your residency.
0 coins