


Ask the community...
For what it's worth, I've had two jobs with very different pay scales for years (one $85K, one about $5K). I never check the multiple jobs box and just claim single/zero on both W-4s. This has always resulted in a refund at tax time. The withholding from my main job covers most of my tax liability, and the little bit withheld from my smaller job is just extra cushion. Simple approach but it works for me!
But doesn't the new W-4 not have allowances anymore? I thought they got rid of the "0 allowances" option in 2020 when they redesigned the form.
You're absolutely right, and I should have been more clear. On the new W-4 form, I don't check the multiple jobs box, and I don't claim any adjustments to income or deductions. This effectively results in maximum withholding (similar to what "0 allowances" used to do on the old form). The principle is the same though - I let my main job withhold at the standard rate, and then my smaller job also withholds at the standard rate. Since the withholding tables don't "know" about my other job, I end up with a bit more withheld than necessary, which gives me a refund rather than owing taxes.
I made a huge mistake with my W-4 last year - checked the multiple jobs box for both my main job ($90K) and my weekend job ($7K), and they BOTH withheld as if I was making double the income at each job. Got a massive refund but my paychecks were tiny all year! Don't overthink it - with such a small second job, just make sure you're withholding enough at your main job. The IRS withholding calculator on their website can help you figure out the exact amount if you want to be precise.
13 Just FYI - those emails from exchanges are automated and sent to everyone. The exchanges are required to report to the IRS, but that doesn't mean you personally have a filing requirement. In your situation with: 1. No job income 2. Only $1 in crypto with a small loss 3. Being 18 years old You're well below the filing threshold. The IRS doesn't expect you to file a return when you have essentially no income and just a tiny investment loss.
5 If OP did have to file though, would the loss on Bitcoin be deductible against other income? Or do you have to have gains to report crypto stuff?
13 Capital losses (including from crypto) can be deducted against capital gains, and up to $3,000 can be deducted against regular income. In OP's case, the loss is so small (only a few cents) that it wouldn't make a meaningful difference on a tax return. Even if OP had other income that required filing, reporting a 7-cent loss wouldn't result in any tax benefit worth pursuing. If the amount was larger (say, $100+), then it might be worth reporting to offset other income.
10 Does anyone know if the rules are different for minors with crypto? I'm wondering because OP is 18 now but might have been 17 when the transaction happened depending on timing.
21 The age doesn't change the tax rules, but if you're claimed as a dependent on your parents' tax return (which many 18-year-olds are), there are different filing thresholds. For dependents with unearned income (which includes crypto gains), you're required to file if that unearned income exceeds $1,150. In OP's case, there was a loss, not a gain, so it doesn't trigger any filing requirement regardless of dependent status.
You should immediately pull your credit reports too! I had the same issue last year and discovered the tax return was just the beginning - the identity thief had also opened credit cards in my name. Go to annualcreditreport.com (the official site) and check all three bureaus. If you see anything suspicious, place a fraud alert or credit freeze right away. Also, check if your employer, accountant, or any financial services you use had data breaches recently. In my case, my information was leaked through my previous employer's payroll provider.
That's actually really helpful - I hadn't thought about checking my credit reports. Did you end up placing a credit freeze? I'm wondering if that's overkill or a smart precaution at this point.
I absolutely did place a credit freeze with all three bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion). It's free to do, and you can temporarily lift it whenever you need to apply for credit. In my opinion, it's not overkill at all - it's basic protection. After dealing with the nightmare of clearing up the fraudulent accounts that were already opened, I wished I had frozen my credit years ago. Just remember that each bureau requires a separate freeze request, and make sure to keep the PINs they give you for when you need to unfreeze.
Has anyone mentioned that your accountant might have accidentally filed your personal return? This happened to me last year - my CPA had my 2022 return ready for review, but somehow it got e-filed before I approved it. When I tried to file my actual return, I got the same error code. Might be worth checking with them if they prepared a draft that got submitted by mistake.
This happened to me too! My accountant had a new assistant who thought she was supposed to e-file all the prepared returns in the system, including mine which was just a draft. Took months to sort out because I had to file an amended return even though I never approved the original. Definitely check with your accountant before assuming identity theft.
Something everyone's missing in this conversation - qualified retirement plans! While Roth IRAs have that marriage penalty with the lower limits, employer plans like 401ks don't have this issue. Also, don't forget about spousal IRAs - if one of you stops working when the baby comes, the working spouse can still contribute to the non-working spouse's IRA even with no income. This is ONLY available if you're legally married. And remember, with a kid, one of you gets head of household filing status if unmarried, which is better than single filing status but not as good as MFJ in many cases. The higher standard deduction for MFJ vs HOH+Single might offset some of what you're calculating.
I hadn't thought about the spousal IRA angle - that's a good point if one of us takes time off work. For the head of household vs. MFJ comparison, do you know roughly what income levels the breakeven point would be? We're trying to plan for several scenarios.
The breakeven point between HOH+Single vs. MFJ varies widely based on income distribution, deductions, and credits. Generally, if you both make similar high incomes (like your situation), staying unmarried often provides tax advantages. The MFJ advantages typically shine when incomes are very disparate. For 2024/2025, the standard deduction for MFJ is $29,200 while HOH is $21,900 and Single is $14,600. So HOH+Single combined is $36,500 - already higher than MFJ. But when you factor in the different tax brackets, EITC, child tax credits, etc., it gets complicated. The child tax credit phase-out starts at different income levels for different filing statuses. If one of you might take extended time off work with the baby, that's when marriage often becomes more advantageous tax-wise due to the income splitting effect and spousal IRA.
Has anyone mentioned the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)? At your income levels, especially if you're in a high tax state with high property taxes, AMT can kick in and eliminate some deductions when married. Also consider that many tax benefits phase out based on AGI - not just Roth contributions but also student loan interest deductions, rental loss deductions, etc. As a married couple your combined AGI could push you over these limits. Something else to consider - marriage gives you double the capital loss deduction ($6,000 vs $3,000) which matters if you have investment losses to harvest.
Katherine Ziminski
One thing to consider with land sales - the property tax assessor is NOT the authority on fair market value for capital gains purposes. I made this mistake and it caused problems. The IRS cares about the actual amount you sold it for (minus selling expenses) compared to your purchase price (plus improvements). If you've owned the land since 2009, make sure you have documentation of the original purchase and any improvements. If you don't have receipts for improvements, the IRS typically won't allow you to add them to your basis.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
•Thanks, that's really helpful! Actually, my dad has been meticulous about keeping records. He's got the original purchase documents from when he bought it, plus receipts for clearing some areas, putting in a gravel access road, and installing some drainage systems. Would all of those count as improvements to the property?
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
•Yes, all of those would likely qualify as capital improvements that increase your basis! Clearing land, access roads, and drainage systems are classic examples of improvements that add to your cost basis because they're not regular maintenance but actual improvements to the property. Make sure you have those receipts organized and ready to provide if needed. The higher your documented basis, the less capital gain you'll have to report. This is exactly why keeping good records is so important with investment properties.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Just to add - capital gains rates depend on your total income too. If your dad's income is below $44,625 (single) or $89,250 (married) for 2025, the capital gains rate might be 0%! Between that and the next threshold (around $492k single/$553k married) it's 15%. Above that it's 20%. Plus some states add their own capital gains taxes on top of federal.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
•I thought capital gains on real estate was always 15% regardless of income? Is that not the case?
0 coins