


Ask the community...
UPDATE: We got the decision letter today!! The judge ruled in our favor! I'm so relieved I could cry. The letter says the previous determination is reversed and my husband is eligible for benefits. It explains that his reduction in hours constituted a constructive discharge (basically forced quit) which qualifies for benefits. Thank you everyone for helping me stay sane during the wait! Now I just hope the payments come through quickly.
Congratulations Gianna! That's such wonderful news! I've been following your story and I'm so relieved it worked out in your favor. The "constructive discharge" ruling is exactly what should happen when employers cut hours to basically nothing - it's not a true voluntary quit when you're forced into that situation. Hopefully this gives hope to others dealing with similar appeals. Wishing you and your husband all the best, and hopefully those payments come through super quickly!
This is such great news to hear! I'm new to this community but have been dealing with my own EDD issues, and stories like this give me hope that the system does sometimes work correctly. The constructive discharge ruling makes total sense - employers shouldn't be able to game the system by cutting hours to force people out and then claim it was voluntary. Thanks for sharing the update and congratulations on getting the justice you deserved!
Thank you everyone for all this helpful advice! I'm going to follow the suggestions about creating a paper trail. I just sent a formal email to HR summarizing our conversation and specifically requesting intervention. I'll give them two weeks to address it, and in the meantime, I'll continue documenting any further incidents. I also managed to get through to an EDD representative using the Claimyr service someone suggested. The rep confirmed that harassment can qualify as good cause to quit, but I need to show I tried to resolve it first. They suggested I keep a detailed log with dates/times/descriptions of incidents and any witnesses present. If things don't improve after my formal complaint, I'll draft a resignation letter specifically citing the hostile work environment as the reason. I'm still hoping it won't come to that, but at least I feel more prepared now if it does. I'll update this thread once there's a resolution.
Good luck with your situation! I went through something similar about 6 months ago and it's such a stressful process. One thing that really helped my case was keeping a detailed incident log with exact quotes when possible - EDD asked me very specific questions during my phone interview about what was said and when. Also, don't forget to save any work emails or messages that might support your case. In my situation, my supervisor had sent some pretty unprofessional emails that helped demonstrate the hostile environment. The EDD rep said having contemporaneous documentation (stuff created at the time, not written later) was really important. Really hope HR actually does something to fix this for you so you don't have to leave. But if you do end up quitting, sounds like you're building a solid case. The fact that HR already acknowledged the behavior was inappropriate should definitely help if it comes to that.
That's really solid advice about the contemporaneous documentation! I hadn't thought about saving work emails but you're absolutely right - I should check if there are any unprofessional messages from my supervisor that I can screenshot before I potentially leave. The incident log is something I started after reading the earlier comments, and I'm trying to be as detailed as possible with dates, times, and exact quotes when I can remember them. It's honestly pretty depressing to write it all down and see how much has actually happened over these past few months. Thanks for sharing your experience - it gives me hope that there's a path forward here even if HR doesn't come through.
Thank you everyone for all this helpful information! I think we're much clearer now on how this works. To summarize what I've learned: 1. He can file for these two weeks and still have benefits available later in the year if needed 2. The claim stays open for 12 months (his benefit year) 3. When he goes back to work, he needs to report earnings on his certification 4. If laid off again, he just reopens the same claim rather than filing a new one 5. He should check if work search requirements are waived, and if not, document some activities just to be safe This community has been incredibly helpful! I'll make sure he keeps all his paperwork organized in case there are any issues down the road.
You've got it exactly right! One more tip - have your husband screenshot or save his UI Online account homepage showing his claim balance and benefit year end date. That way if there are any system glitches later (which unfortunately happen sometimes), he'll have proof of his remaining benefits. Also, construction workers often qualify for higher benefit amounts due to the seasonal nature of the work, so don't be surprised if his weekly benefit amount is decent even for short-term claims. Good luck to both of you!
UPDATE: I just got through on the website (10:45pm). Seems like they've fixed whatever was causing the outage. Try certifying now before everyone else realizes it's working!
I'm dealing with the exact same issue! Been locked out since Sunday trying to certify. This is so frustrating because I have bills coming up too. I tried calling the phone line multiple times but it just disconnects after the "high volume" message. Really hoping this gets resolved soon - it's stressful enough being unemployed without having to worry about technical issues preventing us from getting our benefits. Has anyone had luck with the mobile app or is that down too?
The mobile app has been having the same issues as the website - they use the same backend system. I tried it yesterday and got the same error messages. Based on what others are saying here, it sounds like the system is slowly coming back online for some people. @Keisha Brown mentioned getting through around 10:45pm, so maybe try again during off-peak hours like really late at night or very early morning when fewer people are online. Don t'stress too much about the deadline - from what I ve'read, EDD extends certification windows when there are widespread technical problems like this.
Zara Khan
The call in notice response system worked better pre-pandemic when you could visit offices in person. Now it's all phone-based and the infrastructure can't handle the volume.
0 coins
Hiroshi Nakamura
•I miss being able to just walk into an office and talk to someone face to face. This phone-only system is broken.
0 coins
Zara Khan
•Exactly. A 10-minute in-person conversation is now potentially weeks of failed phone attempts. The system regressed.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
Final update: Got my call in notice response completed using automated calling service. Took 28 minutes total vs the 6 days I spent trying manually. Should have done it from day 1.
0 coins
StarSurfer
•Thanks for the update! I'm definitely going to try Claimyr tomorrow. After reading everyone's experiences here, it's clear that manual calling just isn't realistic with these tight deadlines. The stress isn't worth it when there are services that actually work.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
•I'm in the exact same situation right now - day 4 of trying to get through for my call in notice response with only 6 days left on the deadline. Reading all these experiences really shows how broken this system is. I think I need to bite the bullet and use Claimyr too. The manual calling approach seems like it could easily eat up my remaining time with no guarantee of success.
0 coins