

Ask the community...
I'm a former SSA field office manager who handled hundreds of survivor benefit cases, and I want to share some critical insider knowledge that could help you navigate this situation more effectively. First, regarding the "benefit preservation scheme" concern raised earlier - while SSA does scrutinize some arrangements, legitimate guardianships established for valid reasons are still fully recognized. The key is demonstrating that the guardianship serves the child's best interests beyond just financial considerations. Here's what SSA considers legitimate reasons for guardianship over adoption: - Preserving inheritance rights from biological father's family - Maintaining access to father's veteran/union/employer benefits - Continuing established medical/therapeutic relationships tied to father's insurance - Preserving the child's legal connection to father's family for emotional/cultural reasons When calling SSA, use this exact phrasing: "I'm researching how adoption affects survivor benefits for educational purposes. What is SSA's policy when a stepparent adopts a child receiving survivor benefits?" This frames it as general research rather than a personal situation. Most importantly - SSA has a 60-day grace period for reporting family changes. If you do proceed with any legal arrangements, you have 60 days to report them without penalty. Use this time wisely to ensure all paperwork is filed correctly. One final tip: Request written confirmation of any verbal information SSA provides. Ask them to send a letter confirming their policy explanation to your address. This creates an official record that protects you if there are any future disputes about what you were told.
This insider perspective is absolutely invaluable! Thank you for breaking down the legitimate reasons SSA accepts for guardianship - having that clear framework helps me understand what would be considered valid versus suspicious. The exact phrasing for calling SSA is perfect, and I'll definitely request everything in writing. The 60-day reporting grace period is crucial information I hadn't heard anywhere else. Quick question about the legitimate reasons you mentioned - my daughter has been seeing a grief counselor since her father's death, paid for through the survivor benefits. Would continuing that therapeutic relationship count as "established medical/therapeutic relationships"? Also, regarding inheritance rights, her paternal grandparents are still living - would preserving her potential inheritance rights from them be considered legitimate even if there's no formal will or trust established yet? I want to make sure I understand all the valid grounds we might have beyond just the financial benefits.
This insider information is incredibly valuable - thank you for taking the time to share your expertise! As someone completely new to navigating these complex benefit situations, having that clear framework of what SSA considers legitimate reasons for guardianship is exactly what I needed. The specific phrasing you provided for calling SSA is perfect - much better than the direct personal questions I was planning to ask. I'm definitely going to request everything in writing as you suggested. The 60-day grace period is crucial information that I haven't seen mentioned anywhere else. One question about the therapeutic relationships - my daughter has been seeing a grief counselor to help process her father's death, and we've been using the survivor benefits to pay for these sessions. Would maintaining that established therapeutic relationship count as one of the legitimate medical reasons you mentioned? Also, when you reference preserving inheritance rights from the biological father's family, does that include potential future inheritance from living grandparents or other relatives, even if there's no formal estate planning in place yet? I want to make sure I understand all the valid grounds we might have for guardianship beyond just the financial considerations.
As someone who went through a similar situation, I want to emphasize how important it is to get multiple professional opinions before making this decision. I consulted with three different attorneys - one specializing in family law, one in Social Security benefits, and one in estate planning - and each brought up different considerations I hadn't thought of. One thing that really helped me was creating a detailed financial comparison spreadsheet. I calculated not just the immediate loss of survivor benefits, but also factored in things like the tax advantages of those benefits (they're not taxable income), potential college funding impacts, and what my new husband's financial contribution would need to be to replace that income after taxes. Also consider your daughter's emotional connection to her father's legacy. At 10, she's old enough to have feelings about maintaining that legal connection through benefits versus having a new legal father relationship. Some families find middle-ground solutions like hyphenated names or other ways to honor both relationships. The guardianship route worked well for us, but make sure you understand the differences in your state - some states have limited guardianship options that give specific rights without full parental authority. Document your reasoning carefully and focus on your daughter's best interests in all aspects, not just financial. SSA wants to see that you're making decisions for legitimate family reasons, not just to preserve benefits. Take your time with this decision - there's no rush, and the consequences are permanent.
This is such thoughtful advice about getting multiple professional perspectives - I hadn't considered consulting with three different types of attorneys, but that makes complete sense given how this decision intersects family law, Social Security rules, and estate planning. Creating a detailed financial comparison spreadsheet is brilliant too. You're absolutely right that I need to factor in the tax-free nature of survivor benefits versus taxable replacement income from my fiancé. The point about considering my daughter's emotional connection to her father's legacy really resonates with me. At 10, she does have strong feelings about her dad and might have opinions about what maintaining that legal connection means to her. I love the idea of finding middle-ground solutions like hyphenated names to honor both relationships. The reminder that there's no rush is so important - I've been feeling pressured to make this decision quickly, but you're right that the consequences are permanent and deserve careful consideration. Thank you for emphasizing the importance of documenting legitimate family reasons beyond just financial considerations. This whole thread has shown me how complex this decision really is!
I'm so sorry you're dealing with this incredibly frustrating situation! I went through almost the exact same thing with my elderly father last year when he moved to memory care. The SSA's refusal to recognize standard POA documents is absolutely maddening when you're just trying to help your parents with basic administrative needs. Based on all the excellent advice in this thread, here's what I'd recommend as your best path forward: 1. **Start with USPS mail forwarding immediately** - This gives you a safety net while you work through the SSA paperwork. You can set it up online and it lasts up to 12 months. 2. **Get medical documentation** - Ask your parents' doctor for a letter stating they have "limited mobility and cognitive impairment that prevents them from managing complex administrative tasks." This specific phrasing seems to carry weight with SSA staff. 3. **File SSA-1696 forms for both parents** - Have them sign multiple copies while your dad is having good cognitive days. Get them notarized at a UPS store or similar facility. 4. **Call SSA and specifically ask for a "disability specialist"** - Don't waste time with general representatives. Call right when they open (8 AM) for shorter wait times and less rushed specialists. 5. **Consider Representative Payee status for your dad** - Given his dementia, this might be more appropriate than the SSA-1696 and is designed specifically for beneficiaries with cognitive impairment. Also check with your parents' assisted living facility - they likely have social workers who deal with these SSA issues regularly and may have established relationships with local office staff. You're doing an amazing job advocating for your parents through this bureaucratic nightmare. The system shouldn't be this complicated, but persistence really does pay off. Hang in there! 💪
This is such a comprehensive and well-organized summary of all the best strategies from this thread! As someone who's just starting to navigate this process, having it all laid out step-by-step like this is incredibly helpful. I'm particularly grateful for the emphasis on starting with mail forwarding right away - that immediate safety net takes so much pressure off while working through the more complex SSA paperwork. And the specific phrasing for the doctor's letter is exactly the kind of detail I needed. The distinction between SSA-1696 and Representative Payee status for Dad's situation is really important too. Given his dementia progression, the Representative Payee route might indeed be more appropriate for long-term management of his benefits. Your suggestion about calling right at 8 AM for disability specialists is brilliant - I would never have thought about timing strategy, but it makes perfect sense that they'd be less rushed early in the day. Thank you for taking the time to synthesize all this advice into such a clear action plan. This thread has been absolutely invaluable for families dealing with these SSA challenges. It's amazing how much practical wisdom everyone has shared! 🙏
I'm so sorry you're dealing with this exhausting situation! I just went through something incredibly similar with my grandmother earlier this year, and the SSA bureaucracy is absolutely maddening when you're trying to help elderly family members who can't handle these complex processes themselves. Reading through all the fantastic advice here, I wanted to add one more tip that really helped me: when you visit the SSA office (after getting all your paperwork in order), bring a small folder with dividers containing: 1. Original signed SSA-1696 and SSA-1 forms plus 3-4 copies of each 2. Your legal POA documents (original + copies) 3. Medical letter from their doctors (original + copies) 4. Your government-issued ID 5. Their Social Security cards and/or benefit letters 6. Proof of new address (assisted living admission paperwork) 7. A simple one-page summary sheet with both parents' basic info (names, SSNs, DOBs, old address, new address) Having everything organized and readily available made such a difference with the SSA staff. They could see I was prepared and legitimate, which seemed to make them more willing to help work through the accommodation process. Also, if you run into resistance about the in-person appearance requirement, calmly ask to speak with the office manager and reference the SSA-1696 instructions that specifically mention accommodations for physical and mental limitations. Sometimes the front desk staff aren't fully familiar with all the accommodation procedures. Your persistence and advocacy for your parents is truly admirable. This process is unnecessarily complicated, but you're doing everything right! 💪
This organizational approach is absolutely brilliant! I'm definitely going to create a folder system like this before I attempt any in-person visits. Having everything clearly organized and readily available would definitely show SSA staff that I'm serious and prepared, which could make all the difference in how willing they are to help. I especially appreciate the tip about including a one-page summary sheet with all the basic information - that's such a smart way to keep everything at your fingertips without having to fumble through multiple documents when they ask for details. And bringing multiple copies of everything is genius since it sounds like different offices or staff members sometimes want to keep originals. Your advice about asking for the office manager when facing resistance about the in-person requirement is really valuable too. Having that specific reference to the SSA-1696 instructions about accommodations gives me concrete language to use if I encounter pushback. Thank you for sharing such practical, detailed advice! This thread has given me so much confidence that there are real solutions to this bureaucratic nightmare. Your grandmother was lucky to have someone so well-prepared advocating for her! 🙏
As a newcomer to this community, I want to thank everyone for sharing such detailed and helpful experiences! I'm currently facing what sounds like a very similar situation - I believe I applied for Social Security retirement benefits a few months ago but can't locate any confirmation or status information anywhere. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly enlightening. The distinction between incomplete applications (sitting in the "Continue Application" section) versus properly submitted applications that just don't show up online for months is really important to understand. I had no idea that the SSA website saves partial applications or that it's so common for people to think they've submitted when they've only saved a draft. The tip about checking the "Continue Application" section is something I never would have thought to look for - it sounds like this has helped so many people in this thread! I'm also grateful for the clarification about Medicare Part A eligibility for those applying for early retirement. Like several others here, I had assumed it would be automatic, but now I understand why I wasn't seeing any Medicare-related confirmations. I'm planning to check my MySocialSecurity account first thing tomorrow morning during off-peak hours and look carefully for that "Continue Application" section. If that doesn't pan out, I'll try calling right at 8 AM as several people have recommended. This community is such a valuable resource for navigating these government processes - thank you all for being so generous with your time and experiences!
Welcome to the community, Rita! As someone who's also new here and just went through this exact same stressful situation, I can't emphasize enough how much this thread has helped me understand what's going on with SSA applications. Your plan to check during off-peak hours is smart - I've found the website is much more stable early in the morning. When you're looking for that "Continue Application" section, don't get discouraged if it's not immediately visible. On my account, I had to scroll down and look under different menu sections before I found it. One thing that really struck me from reading everyone's experiences is how this incomplete application issue seems to affect so many people. It's almost like a rite of passage with the SSA website! The good news is that if your application is sitting there partially completed, you should be able to finish it without any issues. I'm keeping my fingers crossed that you find your application tomorrow morning. Based on all the success stories shared here, there's a really good chance it's waiting for you in that section. This community has been such a lifeline for understanding these confusing government processes - I'm so glad we found this helpful discussion!
As a newcomer to this community, I'm so grateful to have found this thread! I'm dealing with almost the exact same situation - I'm convinced I applied for Social Security retirement benefits several months ago but can't find any trace of it in my MySocialSecurity account. Reading through everyone's experiences has been incredibly reassuring. It's both comforting and alarming to see how many people have encountered this same issue with the SSA website! The tip about checking the "Continue Application" section is something I never would have thought to look for, and it sounds like it's helped so many people here successfully complete their applications. I had no idea that the website saves partial applications or that it's so easy to think you've submitted when you've only saved a draft. The distinction between having a confirmation number/email (properly submitted) versus having neither (likely incomplete) really helps clarify what might have happened. I'm planning to log into my account early tomorrow morning and carefully search for that "Continue Application" section. If I can't find anything there, I'll try calling right at 8 AM as several people have recommended. Thank you to everyone who has shared their experiences and practical advice - from taking screenshots of every page to calling during off-peak hours. This community is such a valuable resource for navigating these confusing government processes!
Welcome to the community, Mateo! I'm also new here and just went through this exact same nerve-wracking experience a couple weeks ago. This thread has been such a lifesaver - it's amazing how many of us have fallen into this same SSA website trap! Your plan sounds perfect. When you're searching tomorrow morning, make sure to really dig around in your account interface. On mine, the "Continue Application" section wasn't where I expected it to be - I had to click through a few different menu areas before I spotted it. Don't give up if it's not immediately obvious! What really helped me was Jessica's tip about looking under dropdown menus that need to be expanded. The SSA website seems to hide things in the most unexpected places. I was about ready to call and start panicking when I finally found my partial application just sitting there waiting for completion. The screenshot advice from earlier in the thread is gold too - I made sure to capture every single page when I completed my application, especially that final confirmation screen. After going through this stressful experience once, I never want to question whether I actually submitted something again! Best of luck with your search tomorrow. Based on all the success stories here, I have a really good feeling your application is going to be waiting there for you!
I wanted to share my experience since I went through this exact conversion about 18 months ago. The good news is that everyone here is right - your SSDI conversion to retirement benefits at FRA won't penalize your future spousal benefits at all. One thing I wish I had known beforehand: make sure to keep a copy of your original SSDI award letter and any annual COLA notices you've received. When I applied for spousal benefits after my husband filed, the SSA representative initially had trouble accessing my full disability history in their system. Having those documents made the process much smoother. Also, don't be surprised if your monthly payment date changes slightly when the conversion happens. Mine shifted by a few days because retirement benefits follow a different payment schedule than SSDI (based on birth date rather than when you first became entitled to disability). It's a minor thing but good to know for budgeting purposes. The automatic conversion really is seamless - you'll get a notice in the mail explaining the change, but your benefit amount stays exactly the same. Then when your husband files and you apply for spousal benefits, you should get that nice boost everyone mentioned. Best of luck with your planning!
This is incredibly helpful, especially the tip about keeping documentation! I never would have thought about the payment date potentially changing - that's the kind of detail that could catch someone off guard if they're not expecting it. I'm definitely going to dig up my original award letter and make sure I have copies of everything. It's so valuable hearing from people who have actually been through this process rather than just getting theoretical answers. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience!
I'm going through a similar situation and this thread has been incredibly informative! Just wanted to add one more piece of advice based on my research - when you do apply for spousal benefits in 3 years, make sure to specifically ask the SSA representative to confirm that your SSDI conversion date is being used as your retirement filing date, not any earlier date. I've read about cases where the system initially flagged people as having "early filed" because of their SSDI start date, even though that's incorrect. Most of the time it gets sorted out quickly, but asking them to verify this upfront could save you from any temporary payment issues. Also, since you mentioned budget planning - remember that when you start receiving the spousal benefit top-up, it will also be subject to annual COLAs just like your current benefit. So that extra amount should grow over time too. Your situation sounds very similar to mine and it's reassuring to see so many knowledgeable responses here. The community really came through with solid advice!
Jamal Carter
As someone who recently went through a similar WEP situation, I wanted to share another resource that might help while you're trying to get through to SSA. The AARP website has a pretty detailed WEP calculator that can give you a rough estimate of your reduction based on your pension amount and years of substantial Social Security earnings. It's not as accurate as talking to an SSA rep directly, but it can help you get a ballpark figure while you're waiting to connect with someone. I used it before my appointment and it was within about $50 of what the SSA specialist calculated for me. Also, if you're comfortable with it, some fee-only financial planners who specialize in retirement planning are really knowledgeable about WEP calculations and can walk you through the process. Obviously you'll still want to verify everything with SSA directly, but it might help you understand the basics and prepare better questions for when you do get through. The 9am strategy definitely works - I got through in 12 minutes last Tuesday using that approach!
0 coins
Charity Cohan
•Thanks for sharing the AARP calculator resource! That's really helpful to know there's at least a way to get a rough estimate while dealing with the SSA phone system nightmare. Being within $50 of the actual calculation sounds pretty accurate for planning purposes. I'm definitely going to check that out while I continue trying the 9am calling strategy. The idea about fee-only financial planners is interesting too - I hadn't thought about getting professional help with understanding WEP before talking to SSA directly. It might be worth it just to go into the call more prepared with better questions. It's so encouraging to hear another success story with the 9am approach - 12 minutes is amazing compared to the multi-hour holds everyone was describing! I'm feeling much more optimistic about getting through this process after reading all these strategies and resources.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
As someone who just went through this exact same process, I completely feel your pain! I had the same WEP questions about my state pension and spent WEEKS trying to get through to SSA. What finally worked for me was calling my local office at exactly 9:00 AM when they opened - got through in under 20 minutes! The rep was able to calculate my WEP reduction on the spot and it was actually $400 less per month than I had estimated using online calculators. Also, make sure to specifically ask for a written benefit estimate when you get through - having those numbers in writing is incredibly helpful for retirement planning. The phone system is absolutely terrible, but don't give up! The early morning strategy really does work, and once you get the right person on the line, they're usually very knowledgeable about WEP calculations. Hang in there!
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
•This gives me so much hope! I've been struggling with the same WEP questions for my municipal pension and have had zero luck with the phone system so far. The fact that your actual reduction was $400 BETTER than expected is really encouraging - it shows how much these online estimates can be off in either direction. I'm definitely setting my alarm early tomorrow to try the 9am strategy. Did you have to provide specific pension documents when you called, or were they able to work with just the basic information about your expected monthly benefit amount? I want to make sure I have everything ready when I finally get through!
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
•That's such great news that your reduction was better than expected! I'm in a similar boat with a state teacher's pension and WEP questions. When you called at 9am, did you call the national number or your specific local office directly? I want to make sure I'm using the most effective approach. Also, did the rep give you the written estimate right away or did you have to request it specifically? I've been putting off dealing with this because the phone system seemed impossible, but hearing all these success stories is really motivating me to try again!
0 coins