


Ask the community...
I'm at week 10 and facing the exact same situation! They just suggested a position paying $39K when I was making $78K previously - literally 50% of my previous salary. Reading through all these experiences has been incredibly reassuring that I can decline this without jeopardizing my benefits. The consistent advice throughout this thread about being professional but specific is spot-on. I'm planning to respond with something like: "Thank you for thinking of me for this opportunity. However, this position at $39,000 represents only 50% of my previous salary of $78,000, which falls well below the 80% threshold applicable during the first 13 weeks of my claim period. I will continue my active search for positions that better align with my qualifications and experience." What really stands out is how many people are dealing with these inappropriate early suggestions - it seems like it's almost standard for them to test the waters with lowball offers. But seeing everyone successfully handle it while maintaining their benefits gives me confidence this is the right approach. I've already started the documentation spreadsheet that several people recommended, and I'm going to update my work search plan today to emphasize my certifications. Thanks to everyone for sharing such detailed, practical advice - this thread has been invaluable!
Your situation at week 10 with the 50% pay cut is so similar to what I'm dealing with! I'm at week 6 and just got a suggestion for a job paying $30K when I was making $60K before. Reading through everyone's experiences here has been such a relief - I was honestly scared they could just cut my benefits if I said no to any job suggestion, but it's clear that the 80% rule during the first 13 weeks is real protection. The sample email language you shared is perfect - being specific about the exact percentages really drives home that you understand the rules. I'm definitely going to start that documentation spreadsheet today and update my work search plan to highlight my certifications like everyone recommended. It's amazing how common these lowball early suggestions seem to be, but seeing so many successful declines gives me confidence this is totally manageable. Thanks for adding another data point to this incredibly helpful thread!
I'm at week 3 and just got contacted about a position paying $25K when I was making $55K at my last job - that's less than 46% of my previous salary! Reading through everyone's experiences here has been incredibly eye-opening and reassuring. I had no idea about the 80% rule during the first 13 weeks and was honestly terrified they could just cut my benefits if I declined any job suggestion. The consistent advice about being professional but specific with percentages is so helpful. I'm going to send my counselor an email like: "Thank you for the job suggestion. However, this position at $25,000 represents only 45% of my previous salary of $55,000, which falls significantly below the 80% threshold during the first 13 weeks of my claim period. I have specialized skills and certifications that warrant positions closer to my previous compensation level, and I will continue my active job search for more suitable opportunities." I'm also going to start that documentation spreadsheet immediately and update my work search plan to emphasize my industry certifications like everyone recommended. It's amazing to see so many people successfully navigate these inappropriate early suggestions while keeping their benefits intact. This thread should honestly be required reading for anyone starting unemployment in NY - the practical advice and real experiences shared here are invaluable. Thanks to everyone for taking the time to share such detailed guidance!
I'm dealing with the exact same issue here in Albany! Been getting ERR_CONNECTION_RESET since Tuesday and it's driving me crazy. My certification is due tomorrow and I'm panicking. I tried all the usual troubleshooting - different browsers, clearing cache, restarting router, even tried from a different location with different wifi. Nothing works! Seeing everyone's comments makes me feel less alone in this mess. Definitely gonna try the 5am approach that @Zara Shah mentioned - sounds like that might be our best bet right now. Also documenting everything like @Douglas Foster suggested just in case I need to prove the system was down. Has anyone had luck calling the regular unemployment line recently or is everyone getting those insane hold times? This whole situation is so stressful when you're already dealing with unemployment 😔
@Lucy Lam I feel you on the stress! I m'new here but dealing with the same nightmare. Been trying since Wednesday with no luck. The regular phone line is a joke - waited 6 hours yesterday and never got through. I m'definitely trying that 5am trick tomorrow too. We got this! Also saw someone mention checking their Twitter for updates - might be worth following @nysdol for any official announcements about the outage. Stay strong! 💪
Hey everyone, just wanted to share that I finally got through this morning around 6:15am after reading all your suggestions! The site was extremely slow but functional. For anyone still struggling, here's what worked for me: 1. Used incognito mode in Chrome 2. Had all my info written down beforehand 3. Didn't click anything twice even when it seemed frozen 4. Let each page fully load before proceeding The whole process took about 45 minutes vs the usual 10 minutes, but I got my certification submitted! Don't give up - that early morning window seems to be the sweet spot. Thanks especially to @Amara Nnamani and @Zara Shah for the helpful tips. Hang in there everyone, you'll get through! 🙏
@Felicity Bud Thank you so much for sharing what worked! This gives me hope - I m'definitely trying the early morning approach tomorrow. Question though - when you say don "t'click anything twice even when it seemed frozen ,"how long did you typically wait before assuming the page was actually loading vs actually frozen? I m'worried about timing out but also don t'want to mess things up by being impatient. Also did you notice if the mobile version works any better during those early hours or should I stick with desktop? Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences here! 🙏
If you're having trouble getting through to NYS Department of Labor to ask questions about your specific situation, I had good luck using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get connected to an actual agent. They have a video demo at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI that shows how it works. Saved me hours of trying to call myself when I had questions about my base period wages.
Interesting, I've never heard of that service. Is it legit? I might need to talk to someone if my claim gets complicated.
Just wanted to add that you should definitely file your claim as soon as possible since there's a waiting period before benefits start. New York has eliminated the unpaid waiting week, but there can still be processing delays. Also, make sure you have all your employment documentation ready - W-2s, pay stubs, and any separation paperwork from your employer. The $75k salary you mentioned shouldn't be an issue at all for eligibility, and you'll likely qualify for close to the maximum weekly benefit amount.
This is really helpful advice! I didn't realize NY eliminated the waiting week - that's great news. I do have all my employment docs ready since I just got laid off last month. One quick question though - when you say I'll likely qualify for close to the maximum weekly benefit, is that because my $75k salary puts me in the higher benefit tier? I'm still trying to understand how they calculate the actual dollar amount.
Yes, exactly! Your weekly benefit amount is calculated as roughly half of your average weekly wage during your highest-earning quarter in the base period, up to the state maximum. With a $75k salary, you're likely earning around $1,440 per week, so half of that would be about $720 - but since NY caps it at $504, you'd get the maximum weekly benefit. The formula can be a bit more complex depending on how your earnings were distributed across quarters, but higher earners like yourself typically hit that $504 ceiling pretty easily.
I had a similar issue with flagged claims in the Albany area. What worked for me was going to the career center early in the morning (like 8:30 AM sharp) and asking to speak with someone about "claim resolution" rather than just general unemployment questions. They were more likely to help with specific claim issues rather than just directing me to call the phone line. Also bring all your documentation - pay stubs, separation notice, any correspondence from DOL. Sometimes they can at least tell you what's causing the flag even if they can't fix it on the spot.
@Mateo Warren This is super helpful! I m'dealing with the same flagged claims issue. When you went early and asked about claim "resolution, were" they able to actually update your claim status in their system, or did they just explain what was causing the problem? I m'trying to decide if it s'worth the trip to my local office or if I should keep trying other methods to get through.
@Mateo Warren This is really good advice about the early morning timing and specific wording! I ve'been struggling with the same phone system issues. Quick question - when you brought all that documentation, did they actually have access to look up your claim in their system at the career center? I m'wondering if the staff there can see the same information as the phone agents or if they re'working with limited access. Trying to figure out if it s'worth gathering everything up for the trip.
The Rochester One-Stop Career Center on East Main Street is usually your best bet for in-person help. They're typically open 8:30 AM - 4:30 PM weekdays, but like others mentioned, definitely call first. I had success there a few months ago by arriving right when they opened and specifically asking to speak with someone about "unemployment claim issues" rather than just general questions. The staff there seemed to have more access to the system than I expected. Also, if you can't get through to them by phone, try using the online chat feature on the NYS DOL website during off-peak hours (like early morning or late afternoon) - sometimes that's faster than calling.
CosmicCrusader
Just went through this exact situation last month! You definitely want to keep filing your weekly claims and report all work accurately. I made the mistake of thinking I should stop filing completely when I got a job, but then the position ended after just 2 weeks and I had to go through the whole process of reopening my claim. It was a nightmare and delayed my benefits for weeks. The key is being consistent with your weekly certifications - report everything truthfully and let the system calculate your benefits. Your claim will essentially be "dormant" while you're working full-time but ready to activate again if needed.
0 coins
Connor Byrne
•That's really helpful to know about keeping the claim active! I was definitely leaning toward stopping my weekly filings completely. How long did it take you to reopen your claim when that job ended? I'm worried about gaps in coverage if something similar happens to me.
0 coins
Ingrid Larsson
Thanks everyone for the helpful advice! I feel much better about this now. I'll definitely keep filing my weekly claims and just report my work hours and earnings accurately. It's reassuring to know the claim stays active in case things don't work out with the new job. @CosmicCrusader your experience is exactly what I was worried about - glad I asked here before making that mistake!
0 coins
Oliver Fischer
•This whole thread has been super informative! I'm actually starting a new job next week too and was totally confused about what to do with my unemployment claim. It's such a relief to know that keeping the claim active while reporting work is the right approach. The system seems designed to handle these transitions smoothly if you just stay honest about your earnings and hours. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - it's way more helpful than trying to navigate the DOL website on your own!
0 coins