wait they can take money from your paycheck?? i thought unemployment was supposed to HELP people not make things worse! this system is so messed up

I went through this exact situation last year. Yes, they can garnish your wages, but you definitely have options before it gets to that point. First, absolutely request a hearing within those 30 days - even if you think you might owe something, the amount could be wrong. I found out my overpayment was calculated incorrectly and got it reduced by $1,200. Also, keep all your documentation from when you were filing - pay stubs, work schedules, anything that shows what you reported. If you do end up owing money, they're usually reasonable about payment plans. Don't ignore this though - that's when they move to more aggressive collection methods.

Just to clarify - when people say 'unemployment NYC' they're usually just referring to filing for unemployment benefits while living in NYC. It's still the same NYS Department of Labor system. The benefit amount and rules are the same statewide, though job search requirements might vary slightly by region.

Hey @Niko, one more tip - when you file your claim tonight, make sure you have your last employer's exact business name and address handy. The system is pretty picky about matching the info exactly as it appears on your W-2 or pay stubs. Also, if you worked multiple jobs in the past 18 months, you'll need info for all of them. Good luck with your claim!

To clarify the job search requirements since there seems to be some confusion - it's 3 work search activities per week, not necessarily 3 job applications. This can include networking, attending job fairs, skills training, etc. You do need to keep records including employer name, date, method of contact, and position applied for. Regarding suitable work, in the first 10 weeks you can generally refuse work paying less than 80% of your previous wage, after that the standards become more flexible.

honestly the whole thing is a nightmare. took me 6 weeks just to get my first payment and that was with zero issues on my claim. good luck OP

Yeah my cousin works at one of the NYS Department of Labor offices and she says they're constantly backlogged. Even when unemployment rates look good on paper there's still tons of people cycling through the system - seasonal workers, people between jobs, folks dealing with reduced hours. The numbers you see publicly are just a snapshot.

If you want more detailed breakdowns, the NYS Department of Labor also publishes their Unemployment Insurance Trust Fund reports quarterly which show total benefit payments and recipient counts by region. You can find these buried in their "Data & Statistics" section. The winter months typically see the highest claims due to construction and hospitality layoffs. What's frustrating is they don't publish real-time adjudication queue numbers, so there's no way to know if you're number 100 or 10,000 in line for review.

The unemployment website says average wait time is 12 minutes LMAOOOOO what a joke. I've never waited less than an hour and that's IF I can even get in the queue. Who comes up with these fake stats?

I feel your pain - went through this exact nightmare last year. After 6 weeks of getting nowhere with the regular phone line, I finally got connected using a callback service called Claimyr. They handle all the calling and waiting for you, then connect you when they reach an actual human. Cost me like $20 but saved literally weeks of my life sitting on hold. Got my whole claim sorted in one 15-minute call once I had an agent. The NY system is completely broken - they know people will give up if it's hard enough. Don't let them win, your benefits are money YOU paid into the system!