Just went through this exact situation. The key is to gather all your documentation before you appeal. I had to pay back $1,400 but it turned out I actually did make a mistake with reporting some freelance work. If you truly reported everything correctly, you should be able to get the overpayment reversed. NYS Department of Labor makes mistakes too, but you need proof to challenge it.

I went through something similar last year and it was stressful but manageable. First thing - don't panic and don't ignore it. The $2,100 overpayment could be due to several reasons: miscalculated weekly benefit amounts, unreported earnings, or even their system error. You absolutely have rights here. Request your full payment history and earnings records from my.ny.gov, then compare them with your own records of reported income. If everything matches up and you reported correctly, file an appeal within 30 days. Even if you do owe money, NYS Department of Labor typically allows payment plans - I've seen people pay as little as $50-75 monthly. The important thing is to respond and engage with the process rather than avoiding it.

Wait, are we talking about regular unemployment or standby? Because if you're on standby status the rules are totally different. I was on standby for 6 months last year when my factory had temporary layoffs.

The whole system is confusing! I wish NYS Department of Labor would just give us a simple chart showing how many days/weeks we get instead of making us dig through all their documentation.

Here's what you need to do step by step: 1. Keep a copy of your fraud form submission (screenshot or confirmation number) 2. Call using claimyr.com to get through to an agent - regular phone lines are impossible 3. Have ready: SSN, old W2s, any old claim info you can find, proof of identity 4. Ask specifically for the PIN reset department 5. If first agent can't help, ask to speak with a supervisor I went through this exact thing last month. The system is ancient and terrible at handling old claims, but there are people who can fix it. Don't give up! claimyr.com saved me hours of hold time.

Had this exact same issue last year! The security questions from decades ago are a nightmare. Here's what finally worked for me: I went to my local career center (One-Stop office) and they have a direct line to DOL that bypasses the regular phone system. The staff there helped me get connected to someone who could manually verify my identity and reset my PIN on the spot. Way faster than waiting for the fraud form response. You can find your nearest office on the DOL website under "Career Centers" - totally free service too!

Glad you got it resolved! For anyone else reading this thread in the future: there's a difference between resetting your NY.gov ID (which controls access to all NY state services) and resetting your PIN (which is specific to unemployment claims). Make sure you know which one you need help with before calling.

Great advice about keeping track of different government logins! I use a password manager now after getting locked out of multiple accounts last year. One tip I learned the hard way - if you're dealing with both federal (IRS) and state (unemployment) stuff at the same time, open them in different browsers or use incognito mode. It helps prevent the confusion that @NebulaNinja experienced. Also bookmark the specific login pages so you don't accidentally end up on the wrong site!

bruh i swear ny unemployment be playing games with our money 🤡

I went through the exact same thing last year! The base period calculation is honestly the most confusing part of NY unemployment. What helped me was calling the DOL directly (took forever to get through) and having them walk through my wage history quarter by quarter. They were able to explain exactly which quarters they were looking at and why certain wages weren't included. Also double check that all your employers properly reported your wages - sometimes there are delays or mistakes in their reporting that can affect your base period calculation. Don't give up, the system is complicated but there are people there who can help clarify things if you can get through to them!