


Ask the community...
I'm going through the exact same thing right now - been trying to reach someone for 4 days about a payment that's been stuck on "pending" for almost 3 weeks! Reading through this thread has been so helpful, especially seeing Isaiah's success story. I tried calling Thursday afternoon like Fiona suggested and actually got further than usual - made it to the hold music for 20 minutes before getting disconnected, which is progress compared to the immediate busy signals I was getting earlier in the week. I think I'm going to bite the bullet and try Claimyr tomorrow since so many people here had success with it. It's just ridiculous that we're paying for a third-party service to access our own state benefits, but at this point my sanity is worth more than whatever it costs. Has anyone noticed if certain times of day work better with Claimyr, or is it pretty consistent throughout the day?
Hey Miguel! I just signed up for this community after stumbling across this thread while desperately googling NY unemployment tips at 2am (can't sleep because of the stress). I'm in a very similar boat - my claim has been "under review" for 2.5 weeks now and I've called probably 40+ times with zero success. Reading everyone's experiences here is both comforting (knowing I'm not alone) and infuriating (that this system is so broken). I'm definitely going to try both the Thursday afternoon strategy and Claimyr based on all the positive feedback here. From what I've read in other forums, Claimyr seems to work consistently throughout the day since they're basically just automated dialing on your behalf until they get through. The real bottleneck is on NY's end, not theirs. Really hoping we both get this resolved soon - the financial stress is killing me!
Just wanted to chime in as someone who went through this exact nightmare about 6 months ago. I was stuck in "pending review" limbo for almost a month and nearly had a mental breakdown from the stress. What finally worked for me was a combination of the strategies mentioned here - I called on Thursday around 3pm AND used the slow SSN entry trick that Fiona mentioned. Got through on my second try that day after weeks of failure. The agent told me my case was flagged because I had filed for unemployment briefly in 2023, and their system flagged it as a potential duplicate claim. Took her literally 3 minutes to clear it once she saw my account. It's absolutely insane that such simple fixes require jumping through so many hoops. For anyone still struggling - don't give up! The system is broken but the agents are actually helpful once you reach them. And definitely have all your info ready because they move fast.
I had trouble getting through to NYS Department of Labor when I needed to speak with someone about my work authorization documents. If you run into issues reaching them by phone, I found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that helped me get through to an actual agent. They have a demo video at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI that shows how it works. It was really helpful when I needed to verify my documentation requirements.
Just want to add that you'll need to meet the same job search requirements as everyone else once you start receiving benefits. Keep track of your job search activities and make sure your work authorization doesn't expire during your benefit period, as that could affect your continued eligibility.
That's a really important point about work authorization expiration! @Chloe Harris, make sure to check your visa expiration date and if it's coming up soon, you might want to speak with an immigration attorney about renewal options. The last thing you want is to have your benefits cut off because your work authorization lapsed.
Hey Sofia! I went through this exact same panic when I first started filing - you're definitely not alone! Here's the simple breakdown that finally made it click for me: you file EVERY Sunday for the week that just ended on Saturday. So this Sunday you'd file for last week. The deadline is actually the following Saturday, giving you a full week to submit it. If you missed last week, don't freak out! You can still file it late through my.ny.gov - look for "File for Previous Weeks" or similar option when you log in. The payment might be delayed but you won't lose it completely. I learned the hard way to set a phone reminder for every Sunday morning - now it's just part of my routine. Also keep a simple notebook or phone notes about your job search activities each week so you can answer those questions accurately even if you're filing late. The NYS system is definitely not user-friendly about explaining this timing, but once you get into the rhythm it becomes second nature!
This is such helpful advice Kayla! I'm so relieved to hear from so many people who went through the same confusion I'm experiencing. The notebook idea for tracking job search activities is really smart - I've been doing my searches but not always writing down the details, which made me nervous about answering those questions accurately. I'm definitely going to start keeping better records going forward. It's amazing how much clearer this all seems now that everyone has explained it step by step. The my.ny.gov interface really could use some better explanations about the timing! Setting up that Sunday reminder right now so I never have to panic like this again.
Sofia, I totally get the panic! I had the exact same confusion when I started filing and missed my second week because I thought the deadlines were different. Here's what worked for me: if you missed filing for last week, log into my.ny.gov and look for the "File Weekly Certification" section - there should be options to file for previous weeks that you can still submit late. The key thing to remember is you're always filing for the week that ended on Saturday, and you have until the following Saturday to submit it. So plenty of time! I set a recurring alarm on my phone for every Sunday at 9 AM with the note "File unemployment claim for last week" - it's been a lifesaver. Even if your late filing delays the payment by a week or two, you won't lose those benefits permanently. Just make sure to answer all the work search questions based on what you actually did during that specific week you're filing for, not what you're doing now. You've got this - the first few weeks are always the most confusing but it becomes routine really quickly!
I'm going through something very similar right now - my company just announced they're moving from Rochester to Manhattan and I'm terrified about losing my benefits. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly helpful and reassuring! It sounds like the key is documenting everything thoroughly and using the right terminology like "constructive dismissal" when filing. The fact that so many people here have successfully gotten approved for similar relocations gives me hope. Does anyone know if there's a specific time limit for filing after your last day of work? I want to make sure I don't miss any deadlines while I'm gathering all my documentation.
You generally have to file for unemployment within 30 days of your last day of work to avoid any potential issues, though NYS allows filing up to a year after job separation. I'd recommend filing as soon as possible after your last day to get the process started. Rochester to Manhattan is an even more extreme case than most mentioned here - that's like 350+ miles! You should definitely qualify given that distance. When you file, make sure to emphasize both the unreasonable distance and the fact that relocating to NYC would likely mean significantly higher living costs that make it financially unfeasible. Document everything about the move announcement and start calculating your potential commute costs and time. Your case sounds very strong based on all the successful examples shared here!
I'm currently dealing with a similar situation where my employer is relocating from Albany to Long Island - about 180 miles away. After reading all these helpful responses, I feel much more confident about filing for unemployment benefits. It's clear that NYS Department of Labor recognizes employer relocation beyond reasonable commuting distance as "good cause" or "constructive dismissal." For anyone else in this situation, the key takeaways seem to be: 1) Document everything about the relocation announcement, 2) Calculate the actual distance and commute time to show undue hardship, 3) Don't let HR discourage you - they're often wrong about unemployment eligibility, 4) File within 30 days of your last work day, and 5) Be very detailed in your application about why the move creates a financial or personal hardship. Syracuse to Buffalo at 150+ miles is definitely well above the threshold based on all these successful cases shared here. Thanks everyone for providing such detailed experiences - it's incredibly helpful for those of us navigating this stressful situation!
Oliver Becker
I just went through this exact situation about 6 weeks ago! When they say "adjudication closed," it basically means they've finished investigating your claim, but the system hasn't updated your payment status yet. It's like they've made the decision but haven't filed the paperwork - super confusing! Here's what finally worked for me: • Call right at 8am when they open (way shorter hold times) • Ask specifically: "What was the adjudication determination - approved or denied?" • Request the "adjudication determination letter" - this forces them to look deeper • Ask when payments will start processing if approved • Keep doing your weekly certifications even though it says pending! My timeline was: filed claim → 2 weeks pending → adjudication closed → 1 more week → first payment hit my account. The waiting is brutal but you're probably much closer than you think! Don't give up - persistence really does pay off with this system. The fact that adjudication is closed is actually a good sign that things are moving forward, even though it doesn't feel like it. Hang in there! 💪
0 coins
Zainab Abdulrahman
•@Oliver Becker This is super helpful! I m'literally in the exact same spot right now - filed about 2 weeks ago and got that confusing adjudication "closed status" yesterday. Your timeline breakdown is exactly what I needed to see because I was starting to panic that something went wrong. The tip about asking for the adjudication "determination letter specifically" seems to be the golden advice everyone keeps mentioning. I ve'been asking generic questions like what "s'my status and" getting nowhere fast. Definitely going to try the 8am calling strategy too - I ve'been calling later in the day and sitting on hold for hours! Really appreciate you sharing your actual timeline from start to finish. Knowing it was only about a week from adjudication "closed to" payment gives me so much hope. I ve'been keeping up with my weekly certifications thankfully, but it s'good to know that was the right move even though everything feels frozen. Thanks for the encouragement too - this whole process has been such a stressful nightmare but hearing success stories like yours keeps me going! 🙏
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! Filed my claim about 18 days ago and just got that confusing "adjudication closed" status when I called yesterday. The phone rep basically just repeated the same line about my case being "under review" without explaining what that actually means for my situation. This thread has been incredibly helpful - honestly way more informative than anything I've gotten from the actual unemployment office. The whole "closed doesn't mean processed" explanation finally makes sense of why I'm stuck in this weird limbo. I was starting to worry that my claim got denied or lost in their system somewhere. Definitely planning to call right at 8am tomorrow (thanks for that tip everyone!) and ask specifically about the "adjudication determination letter" instead of just asking for my general status. Also really glad I saw the advice about continuing weekly certifications - I was honestly considering skipping this week's since everything seems frozen, but sounds like that would be a huge mistake! The fact that so many people are dealing with identical situations really shows how broken their communication system is, but at least we're all helping each other figure it out. This community is honestly a lifesaver when navigating this bureaucratic maze. Will definitely update once I get some real answers! 🤞
0 coins
Felix Grigori
•@Javier Mendoza You re'definitely not alone in this! I just went through something really similar about a month ago and that adjudication "closed status" is so confusing when they don t'explain what it actually means. I was in the same exact headspace - wondering if my claim disappeared or got rejected somehow. The advice everyone s'sharing here about calling at 8am and asking for that specific adjudication "determination letter really" does work! I was asking the wrong questions before and just getting generic responses. Also definitely keep up with those weekly certifications - I almost stopped doing mine too thinking everything was frozen, but it turns out that would have been a major mistake. From what I ve'learned following this thread, you re'probably way closer to getting answers than it feels right now. The closed "status" seems to be more of a processing step than an ending, which is weirdly reassuring even though the waiting is brutal. This community has been such a game changer for actually understanding what s'happening behind the scenes. Good luck with your 8am call tomorrow - really hope you get some clear answers finally! Keep us posted! 💪
0 coins