That's concerning. What specific documentation did they request in the audit? Was it focused more on proving eligibility (the revenue decline) or on the wage calculations?

They wanted both types of documentation. For the eligibility part, they requested quarterly profit and loss statements for both 2019 and 2020 to verify our claimed revenue decline. They also asked for bank statements showing deposits that would substantiate our gross receipts. For the wage calculations, it was much more detailed. They requested payroll registers for all quarters claimed, documentation showing which employees' wages were claimed, evidence of how PPP funds were allocated to specific payroll periods, and health insurance allocation methodology. They even asked for copies of our PPP loan applications and forgiveness documentation to cross-reference. The most time-consuming part was providing a spreadsheet reconciling the qualified wages on our 941-X with our actual payroll records. I recommend creating and saving this type of reconciliation when you do your initial filing - recreating it a year later was a nightmare.

I submitted in January 2023 and just got my refund last month, so about 7 months. But I've heard some people waiting over a year now. The IRS is overwhelmed with these claims and there's been increased scrutiny because of all the fraudulent claims submitted by sketchy ERC mills.

How did you find your CPA? Did you just google or get a referral? I'm worried about ending up with someone who doesn't know what they're doing.

I got a referral from another small business owner friend - definitely the way to go if possible! Ask around to people in similar situations as yours. If that's not an option, check reviews but specifically look at responses from people with tax situations similar to yours. A good interview question is asking potential CPAs about their experience with your specific situation (side business, interstate move, etc). If they start immediately mentioning specific deductions or considerations for your situation without prompting, that's usually a good sign they know their stuff!

That's a really good point about the time aspect. I spent like 6 hours just trying to figure out how to categorize my side business expenses last year with the software, and that was before all these new complications. Maybe paying someone is worth it just for the stress reduction alone!

This is really helpful info. We're definitely planning significant growth - the reason we're putting half back into the business is for expansion. How complicated was the switch from S-Corp to C-Corp? Were there any unexpected consequences?

The switch itself wasn't too complicated - just filing Form 8832 to elect C-Corp tax treatment. The more complex part was adjusting our accounting systems and planning for the different tax treatment. The unexpected consequences were mostly around compensation strategy. As an S-Corp owner, I was focused on taking enough salary to appear "reasonable" to the IRS but not overpaying on payroll taxes. With a C-Corp, the incentives flip - higher salaries (which are deductible to the corporation) can sometimes be more tax-efficient than dividends. Another surprise was the estimated tax payment schedule for corporations is different from individuals. We had to adjust our cash flow planning to account for that.

Is the QBI deduction permanent though? I thought it was one of those temporary tax law changes that expires soon?

This is good advice but I'm wondering about audits. If the OP puts together all this documentation now in December, doesn't that look suspicious? I've heard the IRS can tell when you're backfilling information.

Creating documentation now isn't suspicious at all - many business owners reconcile their books at year-end. The IRS is concerned with whether expenses are legitimate, not when you organized the records. As long as the expenses actually happened and you have some form of proof (bank statements, receipts, credit card statements), you're fine. The IRS gets concerned when expenses appear fabricated or when there's no supporting documentation at all. They understand that not everyone is a bookkeeping expert, especially first-time self-employed folks. Just be honest, reasonable with your deductions, and keep all the supporting documents you can find.

That's not entirely true. The IRS prefers contemporaneous records, but they do accept reconstructed logs if they're reasonable. I had to do this after losing my mileage notebook, and my accountant said it's acceptable if you can show how you arrived at the numbers using delivery records, maps, etc.

That's a good point I hadn't considered. Do you know if he would need to amend all three years of returns if he decides to recontribute now? Or is there a simpler process?

Yes, he would need to file amended returns for any tax year where he reported income from the distribution. So if he reported 1/3 of it on his 2020, 2021, and 2022 returns, he would need to file amended returns for all three years to get back the taxes he paid on those amounts. There's no shortcut process unfortunately - each year needs its own amended return. The sooner he does it the better, especially for 2020, since the time limit for amendments is approaching. One strategy some people use is to only recontribute the amount necessary to avoid being pushed into a higher tax bracket for those years.

This is correct. I worked at H&R Block that year, and Form 8915-E was specifically for reporting coronavirus-related distributions. Without that form being filed, the IRS would have processed the distribution as a regular early withdrawal subject to the 10% penalty.