


Ask the community...
Something to consider - even though you technically only need to fill out Part 3, I usually fill in zeros for the lines in Parts 1 and 2 that don't apply to me rather than leaving them completely blank. My accountant friend told me that completely blank sections can sometimes trigger additional scrutiny, while zeros clearly show you didn't skip anything by accident. Probably doesn't matter much either way, but thought I'd share what I've been doing for years without any issues.
If you put zeros in Parts 1 and 2, do you need to do any calculations or just literally put 0 in each box? And have you ever been audited or questioned about your Roth withdrawals?
You just put a zero in each box, no calculations needed for parts that don't apply to your situation. It's just to show you didn't accidentally skip that section. I've never been audited specifically about my Roth IRA withdrawals. I did get a general review letter once about three years ago, but it was about something completely different (they questioned some business deductions). My Roth withdrawal reporting with the zeros-not-blanks approach has never been flagged in the 12 years I've been doing it this way.
Quick question for everyone - I'm using TurboTax to file and it's automatically filling in some fields in Parts 1 and 2 even though I only have Roth contribution withdrawals. Should I override it to leave those parts blank or just let the software do its thing?
In my experience, let the software do its thing. TurboTax is programmed to complete forms correctly based on your inputs. If it's filling parts 1 and 2, it's probably putting zeros or calculating something based on your overall tax situation that might be relevant. Tax software is designed to handle these nuances.
9 One important thing nobody's mentioned - if you're earning self-employment income, even as a dependent, you can start contributing to a Roth IRA! It's a great way to start saving early. Just make sure you don't contribute more than you actually earn. I started doing this when I was 17 with my freelance income going through my mom's accounts and it was one of the best financial decisions I ever made.
3 Wait, is that really true even if you're claimed as a dependent? I thought dependents couldn't open retirement accounts.
9 Yes, it's absolutely true! Being claimed as a dependent doesn't affect your ability to contribute to a Roth IRA. The only requirements are that you have earned income and don't exceed the contribution limits (either your total earned income or $6,500 for 2023, whichever is lower). Many parents miss this opportunity for their working teens. It's a fantastic way to start building tax-free retirement savings early, and the compound interest over decades is incredible. I opened mine at Vanguard with help from my parents when I was still in high school.
16 Make sure to also consider state taxes in your planning! Depending on where you live, you might need to file a state return as well. I learned this the hard way when I didn't file a state return for my side gig and got a surprise bill with penalties.
Grad student here - I've been filing with 1042-S forms for 3 years now. If you're a tax resident (the substantial presence test applies after 5 years for most student visas), you should treat your 1042-S fellowship income similar to how you'd report scholarship/fellowship income on a 1098-T. Important distinction: For tax residents, the scholarship/fellowship portion used for tuition and required fees is non-taxable, but amounts used for living expenses are taxable. This is different from non-resident treatment.
Thanks for this info! My 1042-S doesn't seem to distinguish between amounts for tuition vs. living expenses - it just has a total in Box 2. How do I determine which portion is taxable vs. non-taxable? Do I need to get additional documentation from my university?
You'll need to look at your student account statement from your university to see the breakdown. The university doesn't typically distinguish this on the 1042-S itself. Compare your total qualified educational expenses (tuition, required fees, but NOT room and board) against the total fellowship amount. Any amount of your fellowship that went toward qualified expenses can be excluded from taxable income, while the remainder (often your stipend for living expenses) is taxable. Your university's financial aid office or international student office should be able to provide the necessary documentation showing this breakdown if you don't already have it.
Has anyone tried using TurboTax for 1042-S reporting? FreeTaxUSA is giving me headaches with my fellowship income.
I used TurboTax last year for my 1042-S and it was better than FreeTaxUSA but still not ideal. You have to enter it under "Less Common Income" then "Other Reportable Income" and then manually type in the details. They still don't have a dedicated form for it, but at least the interview process walks you through it a bit more clearly than FreeTaxUSA.
Has anyone used SimpleTax (now Wealthsimple Tax) for Canadian Non resident taxes? I heard they support non-resident returns but I'm not sure if it's comprehensive enough for my situation with both US and Canadian income.
Don't forget that the deadline for non-resident Canadian returns is still April 30, unlike the US deadline which is in mid-April (or June 15 for US citizens living abroad). I've missed this deadline before and had to pay penalties, so mark your calendar!
Actually, if you have Canadian self-employment income, the deadline is June 15, even for non-residents! But any balance owing is still due by April 30 to avoid interest charges.
Sean Flanagan
Just something to consider - if you're married and file jointly, your spouse's income could generate tax liability that your LLC could offset. My wife had almost no income during her grad school year, but my income allowed us to take full advantage of her education credits.
0 coins
Isabella Oliveira
β’I'm not married, so unfortunately that's not an option for me. But that's good advice for others in a similar situation who might be married!
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
β’That's unfortunate. Another option to consider for future years is timing your education expenses. If you expect more income next year, you might be able to bunch more expenses into that tax year instead. For instance, paying spring semester tuition in January vs December can shift which tax year it counts for.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
Has anyone had success claiming the LLC when taking online courses that aren't part of a degree program? I'm taking some professional development courses that my employer isn't paying for.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
β’Yes! I claimed LLC for coding bootcamp courses last year. The key requirement is that the educational institution needs to be eligible and provide you with a 1098-T. The courses don't need to be part of a degree program for LLC (that's only a requirement for the American Opportunity Credit).
0 coins