


Ask the community...
I'm so sorry you're dealing with this stress while caring for a 7-month-old! This is actually a really common issue that many new parents face with EDD, and you're absolutely right to keep fighting. One thing I'd add to all the great advice here - when you file your Board Appeal, consider requesting that they assign a different administrative law judge if possible. Sometimes the first judge has already formed an opinion about your case that's hard to change, and a fresh perspective can make all the difference. Also, if you can afford it, consider consulting with an employment attorney who specializes in unemployment appeals. Many offer free consultations and some work on contingency. They know exactly how to frame these disability leave cases and can spot issues that non-lawyers might miss. You mentioned feeling confused by the process - that's completely normal! The EDD system is intentionally complex, but you have a strong case based on what you've described. The 18 months of work history plus the SDI coverage should absolutely qualify you. Don't let them wear you down - you deserve these benefits! Keep documenting everything and stay organized. You've got this! 💪
Thank you so much for mentioning the attorney option! I hadn't even considered that, but you're right that a consultation might be worth it. I've been trying to handle this all on my own while juggling everything with the baby, but having a professional look at my case could really help. Do you know if there are attorneys who specifically handle EDD appeals, or should I just look for general employment lawyers? And the suggestion about requesting a different judge is really smart - I definitely felt like the first judge had already made up their mind before I even started talking.
Yes, there are attorneys who specifically focus on EDD and unemployment appeals! I'd recommend searching for "California unemployment benefits attorney" or "UI appeals lawyer" rather than general employment attorneys. Many of them have experience with exactly these types of maternity leave/SDI cases because they come up so frequently. Some even advertise that they handle EDD appeals specifically. You can also check with your local bar association - they often have referral services and can point you toward lawyers who specialize in this area. The fact that you have such clear documentation and a strong legal basis for your case would probably make you an attractive client for a contingency arrangement too. Don't feel bad about needing help - the system is designed to be confusing and you're dealing with a lot right now!
I just wanted to chime in as someone who went through a very similar situation about 2 years ago. The whole SDI vs PFL distinction that others mentioned is HUGE - I wish someone had explained that to me earlier because it was exactly what was tripping up my case too. One additional tip that really helped me during my Board Appeal: I wrote a brief summary letter (like 1 page) that clearly stated my case and attached it as the first page of all my documents. Something like "This appeal concerns EDD's incorrect denial of benefits due to failure to properly account for SDI disability leave under UI Code Section 1253.3" and then bullet points of the key facts. The judges see so many cases that having a clear summary right up front really seemed to help. Also, the timeline document suggestion from Emma is spot-on. I made mine in a simple table format showing each month, what I was doing (working/SDI/PFL), and my wages. It made it super visual and obvious that I had qualifying work history when disability periods were properly excluded. Don't let them intimidate you - you clearly know your case better than that first judge did! The fact that you're organizing everything and learning the specific regulations shows you're on the right track. Keep pushing forward! 👍
That one-page summary idea is brilliant! I've been gathering all these documents but you're right that the judges probably see tons of cases every day. Having everything laid out clearly at the front makes so much sense. I'm definitely going to create both the summary letter and the timeline table you mentioned. It's really encouraging to hear from someone who went through almost the exact same thing and won their appeal. All of these specific tips are giving me so much more confidence that I can actually win this Board Appeal. Thank you for taking the time to share what worked for you!
i wish they explained this stuff clearly on there notices!!! my cousin got his wages garnished 50% cuz he thought filing an appeal stopped everything automatically but it didn't and now hes behind on his car payments
You're absolutely right. The notices should clearly explain that filing appeals or waivers doesn't automatically stop collection actions. Many people learn this the hard way, and 50% wage garnishment is devastating for most households. Always request a formal stay of collection in writing while simultaneously setting up at least a minimal payment plan.
I went through this exact situation last year and learned some hard lessons. Here's what I wish I had known: the 30-day response deadline on your notice means you need to take ACTION, not just submit paperwork. Even though you're filing a DE-100, you should also call EDD immediately to request a temporary collection hold while your hardship waiver is being reviewed. I made the mistake of thinking the DE-100 submission would automatically pause everything, but they continued sending threatening letters and almost started garnishment. Also, keep detailed records of every interaction - dates, times, representative names, confirmation numbers. The system is frustrating but there are people there who will help if you're persistent and follow the right steps. Don't let the fear paralyze you into doing nothing - that's when the penalties really add up.
This is exactly what I needed to hear from someone who's been through it! I was definitely making the mistake of thinking the DE-100 would pause everything automatically. Your point about the 30-day deadline meaning taking ACTION vs just submitting paperwork really clarifies things for me. I'm going to call first thing tomorrow and explicitly request that temporary collection hold while documenting everything like you suggested. Thank you for sharing your experience - it's helping me avoid the same costly mistakes!
I've been dealing with this exact same loop for about 3 weeks now! It's absolutely maddening. What worked for me was trying at around 6 AM when the system isn't as overloaded. I also had to disable all my browser extensions and use incognito mode. Even then, it took me about 5 attempts over different days to finally break through the loop. The system is definitely glitchy, but don't give up! Also, if you have an old laptop or different device, try that too - sometimes it's browser-specific issues causing the problem.
I'm going through the exact same nightmare right now! Been stuck in this loop for over a week. It's like the website is designed by someone who's never actually had to use it. I've tried different browsers, clearing cache, even tried my neighbor's computer - nothing works. The most frustrating part is that you can see the system recognizes you need to file a new claim, but then it just... doesn't let you? It's like being stuck in unemployment purgatory. Really hoping someone here has found a solution that actually works because I'm running out of patience and options! 😤
I totally feel your frustration! I've been in that same loop for about 2 weeks now and it's driving me absolutely crazy. The "unemployment purgatory" description is so accurate - it's like the system knows what you need to do but actively prevents you from doing it. Have you tried the early morning approach that @Nia Jackson mentioned? I m'thinking of setting my alarm for 5:30 AM tomorrow to try at 6 AM sharp. At this point I m'willing to sacrifice sleep if it means breaking through this ridiculous loop! Let me know if you find anything that works - we re'all in this together! 🤞
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! Got my overpayment notice about 3 weeks ago for 9 weeks from 2023. Like you, it was completely unintentional - I think there was confusion about when my part-time job ended versus when I was still certifying. The panic is SO real when you see that big number they want back! I just submitted my DE 1446HW hardship form last week after reading through all the advice here. A few things I learned that might help: 1. Call EDD ASAP to request they pause collections - I used that Claimyr service someone mentioned and it actually worked to get through quickly 2. The hardship form is intimidating but just be thorough and honest about your finances 3. Keep copies of EVERYTHING you submit 4. Don't be afraid to call back if you don't hear anything after a few weeks The waiting is nerve-wracking but from what I'm seeing here, there's definitely hope for getting at least a partial waiver. Hang in there - you're not alone in this mess! EDD's system is confusing and it's not your fault you got caught up in it.
Thank you for sharing your experience! It's honestly such a relief to know I'm not the only one dealing with this nightmare. The panic when you first see that overpayment notice is unreal - my heart literally dropped when I opened it. I'm definitely going to try that Claimyr service to get through to EDD since calling them normally seems impossible. Did they give you any timeline when you requested the collections pause, or did they just say they'd note it? I'm worried they'll start taking money from my current benefits before I even get a chance to submit all my paperwork. Thanks again for the encouragement - it really helps to know others have gotten through this process successfully!
I've been through this exact situation twice unfortunately - once in 2021 and again in 2023. The good news is that based on your description (no fraud language, unintentional overlap), you have a really good chance of getting some relief through the hardship process. A few things that helped me: - Document EVERYTHING about your current financial situation - income, all expenses, debts, medical costs, etc. - When filling out the DE 1446HW, err on the side of providing too much information rather than too little - If you have any documentation from that time period (pay stubs, work schedules, emails), include copies to show the confusion wasn't intentional - Request a payment plan as backup even while pursuing the hardship waiver The first time I got a full waiver, the second time I got approved for a payment plan of $50/month which was manageable. Don't lose hope - EDD knows their system is confusing and they do work with people who made honest mistakes. The key is being proactive and thorough with your application. You've got this!
Tom Maxon
Hi everyone, just made a video about how to call the EDD and reach a live human agent: https://youtu.be/-R4SqP7_JUA
1 coin
Lydia Bailey
I've been dealing with the same frustrating issue! The system seems to automatically disconnect calls after a certain period, even when you're still holding. From what I've experienced, it usually happens during peak call times when their system is overloaded. One thing that's helped me is calling right when they open at 8 AM - the success rate seems much higher then. Also, make sure you're not on speakerphone or using Bluetooth as sometimes the system interprets audio delays as a disconnected call. Keep trying - I know it's incredibly frustrating but persistence eventually pays off with EDD.
0 coins
Liam Sullivan
•@Lydia Bailey Thanks for the tip about calling right at 8 AM! I ve'been trying at random times throughout the day and getting nowhere. The Bluetooth thing is interesting too - I had no idea that could cause disconnections. Have you noticed any difference between calling on different days of the week? I m'wondering if Tuesdays or Wednesdays might be less busy than Mondays when everyone s'trying to call in.
0 coins