


Ask the community...
I'm dealing with this exact same issue right now! Filed my claim last week and got awarded only $174/week when I know I should be getting much more based on my recent earnings. Reading through all these comments has been so helpful - I had no idea about the Alternative Base Period or that you have to specifically request it. Quick question for those who've been through this - when you submitted your appeal, did you include a cover letter explaining your situation, or did you just fill out the DE 1000M form? Also, has anyone tried calling EDD first to see if they can just recalculate it over the phone, or is the formal appeal process the only way? I'm gathering all my Q4 2023 paystubs now and will definitely use that formula someone mentioned to calculate what my benefit should be. This community is amazing - thank you all for sharing your experiences and helping each other navigate this confusing system!
Hey Zara! I included both a cover letter AND filled out the DE 1000M form when I did my appeal. The cover letter helped me explain my specific situation in plain English, while the form is what they officially need for processing. Don't bother calling EDD first - they can't just recalculate it over the phone for ABP requests. The formal appeal is definitely required. Make sure in your cover letter you clearly state "I am requesting recalculation using the Alternative Base Period" and include your calculated expected benefit amount. Also attach copies of all your Q4 2023 paystubs and maybe create a simple spreadsheet showing your quarterly earnings. Good luck!
This thread has been incredibly eye-opening! I'm a newcomer here and had no idea that EDD doesn't automatically use the Alternative Base Period - what a sneaky way for them to minimize payouts. Reading everyone's experiences, it seems like the key takeaways are: 1. File the DE 1000M appeal form ASAP 2. Include detailed documentation (Q4 2023 paystubs, cover letter, calculations) 3. Be crystal clear that you're requesting ABP recalculation 4. Use certified mail AND upload online if possible 5. Keep certifying while waiting for the appeal For those who successfully appealed - did any of you face pushback from EDD initially, or were most appeals approved pretty straightforwardly once you provided the proper documentation? I'm trying to get a sense of how often they actually deny legitimate ABP requests. Also, has anyone dealt with this situation where you had multiple jobs during Q4 2023? I'm wondering if that complicates the calculation at all or if EDD just adds up all the earnings from that quarter regardless of how many employers. Thanks to everyone sharing their experiences - this is exactly the kind of real-world advice you can't find on EDD's website!
Welcome to the community, Freya! Great summary of the key takeaways. To answer your questions - in my experience and from what I've seen others share here, legitimate ABP appeals are usually approved as long as you provide proper documentation and clearly show that your highest quarter in the Alternative Base Period would result in higher benefits. EDD might take their sweet time processing it, but they generally don't deny valid requests when the math clearly supports you. Regarding multiple jobs in Q4 2023 - that actually works in your favor! EDD combines ALL your earnings from that quarter regardless of how many employers you had. So if you worked two part-time jobs that together added up to full-time equivalent earnings, they'll use the total combined amount for the calculation. Just make sure to include paystubs from ALL employers during that period in your appeal documentation. One tip I'd add to your excellent summary - take screenshots of your current UI Online account showing your low benefit amount before filing the appeal, just in case you need to reference the original calculation later. Good luck with your appeal!
Wow, reading through all these experiences has been both frustrating and reassuring at the same time! I'm currently dealing with this exact issue - been locked out for about 10 days now because I can't remember my last payment amount from early 2022. It's honestly mind-boggling that they'd use such a flawed security system that locks out legitimate users while asking for information that's realistically impossible to remember after years. What really stands out to me from this thread is how Jackson came back to share his successful resolution - that kind of follow-up is so valuable for everyone else struggling with this! The 8 AM calling strategy seems to be the real key here, and knowing that EDD reps have alternative verification methods available gives me actual hope instead of just despair. I'm also really encouraged to hear they're phasing out these payment-related security questions. It's about time they recognized this was a terrible approach! For a system that's supposed to help people, creating barriers that prevent legitimate users from accessing their own accounts is just backwards. Thanks to everyone who shared their stories and solutions here. This thread has convinced me to stop procrastinating and make that call tomorrow morning. The community support in dealing with these government bureaucracy nightmares really makes all the difference!
This thread has been such a goldmine of helpful information! I'm in the exact same boat - locked out for over a week now and getting increasingly frustrated with this ridiculous security system. Reading everyone's experiences, especially Jackson's successful resolution, has given me the motivation to finally tackle this head-on instead of continuing to avoid it. What really resonates with me is how many legitimate users are struggling with this while we constantly hear about fraud in the system. It's like they've designed security measures that primarily hurt the people they're supposed to protect! The 8 AM calling strategy seems to be the consistent winner here, and I love that multiple people have confirmed the reps actually have ways to help beyond just those impossible security questions. I'm definitely calling tomorrow morning armed with all the insights from this thread. It's amazing how much more confident I feel about this whole situation just from reading everyone's real experiences rather than trying to navigate the useless EDD website help pages. Thanks to everyone for sharing - this is what online communities are all about!
This thread has been incredibly helpful and shows exactly why peer-to-peer support is so valuable when dealing with government systems! I'm bookmarking this for future reference because the collective wisdom here is way better than anything on the official EDD website. What really strikes me is how this demonstrates a fundamental design flaw in their security system - asking people to remember specific dollar amounts from years ago is just setting everyone up to fail. It's like they prioritized creating barriers over actually helping legitimate users access their accounts. The 8 AM calling strategy that keeps coming up seems to be the real game-changer here. Jackson's 40-minute wait time is honestly much better than I expected based on all the horror stories floating around. And the fact that EDD reps have alternative verification methods available (but don't advertise this clearly) is both reassuring and frustrating at the same time. I'm really glad to hear they're finally phasing out those payment-related security questions. Hopefully other government agencies will learn from this mess and design better user experiences that don't punish people for being human and not memorizing every financial detail from their past!
Absolutely agree about the value of peer-to-peer support! I just found this thread while desperately searching for help with my own EDD lockout situation, and the collective knowledge here is incredible. It's so much more useful than the generic "contact support" advice you get from official channels. You're spot on about the fundamental design flaw - it's like they created a security system that assumes people have perfect memory of financial details from years ago. Who designed this thinking "surely everyone remembers exactly how much their last unemployment payment was from 2+ years ago"? I'm also really impressed by how Jackson came back to share his success story and update everyone about the policy changes. That kind of follow-up is exactly what makes these community discussions so valuable for future people dealing with the same nightmare. The 8 AM calling tip seems to be the golden advice that everyone's confirming works!
To all those having trouble reaching a human at California Unemployment. I just ran across this video that gave me a shortcut to reach a human. Hope it helps! https://youtu.be/Ize0EkN4HDI
I'm dealing with a similar situation - pending payments for weeks now. One thing that helped me was calling right at 8:00 AM when they open, and I kept hitting the prompts quickly: 1-2-1 then your SSN, then 1. Sometimes it takes dozens of tries but I finally got through. Also, make sure you don't have any flags on your account that might be causing the hold - things like identity verification issues or work search requirements. When you do get through, ask them specifically what's causing the pending status. Don't let them just transfer you without an explanation. Good luck Santos!
@Connor O'Brien This is really helpful advice! I'm new to dealing with issues and wasn't sure about the timing strategy. The 8 AM call time makes so much sense - I've been trying randomly throughout the day with no luck. Can you clarify what you mean by "flags on your account"? How would someone check if they have identity verification issues or other problems that might be causing the pending status? I want to make sure I'm prepared with the right questions when I finally get through to someone.
Wow, thanks for the detailed update! This is super helpful. I've been struggling with the same verification code issue for my UI claim. I'm definitely going to check my contact info in UI Online tonight and try calling right at 8am tomorrow. It's encouraging to hear that you actually got through and resolved your issue. The fact that it was an employer documentation problem makes sense - seems like a lot of these "pending" claims are just waiting for some kind of verification or correction that could be handled much more efficiently. Fingers crossed I have similar luck!
Good luck! One thing I learned is to have your verification code ready to enter as soon as you get the text - apparently they expire pretty quickly. Also, if you have any documents ready (like medical forms or employer info), have them handy because the reps can sometimes resolve multiple issues in one call. Hope you get through tomorrow!
This is exactly why I've been putting off dealing with my pending claim for weeks! The thought of waiting hours just to potentially get disconnected because of some verification code I might not receive is so demoralizing. Reading through everyone's experiences here though, it sounds like the key is really making sure your contact info is 100% accurate in UI Online first. I'm going to bite the bullet, double-check all my account details tonight, and try the 8am strategy tomorrow. It's ridiculous that we have to strategize this much just to get basic assistance, but at least there seems to be a path forward. Thanks for sharing your success story - gives me hope that persistence actually pays off sometimes!
I totally understand that feeling of putting it off - I did the same thing for way too long! The whole system feels designed to discourage you, but you're absolutely right that having a strategy helps. One tip that helped me psychologically was treating it like a work project - I set aside a whole morning, had coffee ready, and mentally prepared for the wait instead of hoping it would be quick. Also, if you don't get through on the first try tomorrow, don't give up! Sometimes it takes a few attempts even with the 8am strategy. You've got this!
Hugo Kass
Just wanted to add that when you do apply for CTB, make sure your nursing program is on the approved training list first! You can check this on the EDD website under "Eligible Training Provider List" or ask your program's financial aid office - they usually know. Some programs aren't approved and you'd waste time going through the whole process. Also, if you do get approved for CTB, you'll need to submit monthly progress reports to EDD showing you're maintaining satisfactory academic progress. Good luck with your application!
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
•Great point about checking the approved training list first! I just looked up my program and it is on there, so that's a relief. The monthly progress reports sound manageable too. Thanks for mentioning that - I wouldn't have known about those requirements otherwise!
0 coins
Luca Greco
I went through this exact process last year! One thing I'd add is that if you do get approved for UI and CTB, keep detailed records of everything - your class schedules, grades, attendance, etc. EDD sometimes does random audits of CTB recipients and they'll ask for proof you're actually attending school and making progress. I got audited about 6 months into my program and had to provide transcripts and a letter from my program coordinator. It was stressful but having everything organized made it much easier. Also, don't be discouraged if your initial UI application gets denied - like others said, the appeals process can work in your favor if you have good documentation about trying to keep your job while starting school.
0 coins
Ella Knight
•This is really helpful advice about keeping detailed records! I'm pretty organized with my school stuff already but I'll make sure to keep everything in one folder specifically for EDD if I get approved. The audit thing sounds scary but at least I'll be prepared. Did they give you much notice when they audited you or was it pretty sudden?
0 coins
Aiden Rodríguez
•They gave me about 2 weeks notice, which was actually pretty reasonable. Got a letter in the mail saying they were conducting a routine review and I had 14 days to submit the requested documents. It wasn't as scary as I thought it would be - just had to send in my most recent transcript, a letter from my program showing I was enrolled and in good standing, and copies of my class schedule. The whole thing was resolved within a month. Just stay on top of your paperwork and you'll be fine!
0 coins