

Ask the community...
I'm new to this community and found this discussion really helpful as I'm facing similar decisions. Just wanted to add that for anyone in a similar situation, it might also be worth considering the tax implications of claiming early vs. waiting. If you're both receiving benefits simultaneously, you could end up in a higher tax bracket on your combined Social Security income plus any other retirement income. But if the survivor benefit strategy works out as described here (getting the higher amount), the tax situation might actually improve for the surviving spouse since they'd be filing as single with potentially lower overall income. Just another angle to consider when making these timing decisions!
Welcome to the community, Melissa! That's a really insightful point about the tax implications that I hadn't considered. You're absolutely right that the tax situation could actually improve for the surviving spouse since they'd be filing as single potentially with lower overall household income. It's one of those aspects that gets overlooked when we're focused on just the benefit amounts. Thanks for bringing up that angle - it adds another important layer to the decision-making process for couples planning their Social Security strategy!
As someone who recently went through the Social Security claiming decision process myself, I wanted to share a few additional considerations that might be helpful. First, while everyone has correctly explained that you'd receive the higher benefit amount ($2,850 in your case), don't forget about Medicare premiums - they're automatically deducted from your Social Security benefit, so your actual take-home amount will be slightly less. Second, if you have any pension income or are still working part-time, there could be earnings test implications if you claim before your FRA that are worth discussing with SSA. Finally, I'd suggest running the numbers on your total household income for the next few years - sometimes claiming early makes sense from a cash flow perspective even if it's not optimal from a pure benefit maximization standpoint. The peace of mind of having that income stream can be worth something too. Best of luck with your decision!
Thank you all for the advice! I think I'll try the online application since my situation seems simple enough, but I'll make sure to double-check everything carefully, especially my earnings record. If I run into any issues, I might try that Claimyr service to get through to someone by phone. I appreciate all your help!
good luck! just remember to print EVERYTHING before u hit submit. my neighbor didnt and had no proof when SS said they never got his application!!
As someone who recently went through this process, I'd recommend starting with the online application since your situation does sound straightforward. However, I'd suggest doing a thorough review of your my Social Security account first - check your earnings history going back to your early working years, not just recent ones. Sometimes there are small discrepancies that can add up over time. One thing that might be worth considering: since you stopped working 6 years ago, make sure those zero-earning years aren't negatively impacting your benefit calculation more than necessary. The SSA uses your highest 35 years of earnings, so if you have more than 35 years of work history, those recent zeros might not matter. But if you're close to 35 years, it could be worth double-checking. Also, keep in mind that you can always start online and call if you hit any snags. The online system will save your progress, so you're not locked into finishing it in one session. Good luck with your application!
Just realized something - check your Medicare Summary Notices from the past few months! My uncle had a similar situation and they actually had a tiny note at the bottom of page 3 on his Medicare Summary Notice that mentioned the premium adjustment. Most people never read those things all the way through! Might be worth digging through your mail or logging into your Medicare.gov account to check your recent MSNs.
I'll definitely look through my Medicare notices! I usually just glance at them, so I could have easily missed something. Great suggestion!
I'm dealing with a very similar situation right now! Got about $8,500 deposited last month with zero explanation, also related to Medicare Part B premiums. Like you, I called multiple times and everyone says it's mine but won't put anything in writing. What I ended up doing was creating my own paper trail - I've been keeping detailed notes of every phone call (date, time, representative name or ID number, exactly what they told me). I also screenshot my MySocialSecurity account daily to show the deposit is still there and hasn't been flagged as an error. I'm planning to wait about 60 days before spending most of it, but I did use a small portion ($500) for urgent medical expenses to test the waters. No clawback so far. The anxiety is real though - I completely understand your fear about touching the money. You're definitely not alone in this frustrating situation!
I'm so sorry for your loss. This is unfortunately a common issue right now. When my grandmother passed away last year, we had a similar experience - SSA continued payments for about 4 months despite multiple reports of her death. Here's what I learned: SSA has been severely understaffed and their death reporting system has major delays. The payments you're seeing are considered "overpayments" and yes, they will eventually demand every penny back. However, they typically don't charge interest if you cooperate and return the funds promptly once they officially notify you. My advice: 1) Keep detailed records of every attempt to contact them, 2) Try visiting your local SSA office in person with the death certificate - this often works better than calling, 3) Set aside all those benefit payments in a separate account so you're ready to return them when asked. The good news is they usually offer payment plans if returning everything at once would cause financial hardship. Hang in there - this bureaucratic nightmare will eventually get resolved.
Thank you so much for sharing your experience - it's reassuring to know we're not the only ones dealing with this mess. Four months is crazy! I'm definitely going to try visiting the local office in person like you suggested. Did they give you any trouble when they finally asked for the money back, or were they pretty understanding about the payment plan option?
I went through this exact situation when my father passed away two years ago. The SSA kept depositing his benefits for nearly 6 months despite multiple death reports! What finally worked was going to the local SSA office in person with his death certificate, my ID, and a written timeline of all my previous attempts to report his death. The key things I learned: 1) Always ask for a receipt number when reporting a death - if they can't provide one, the report likely wasn't processed, 2) Keep a detailed log of every phone call, date, time, and who you spoke with, 3) Don't touch those funds - put them in a separate savings account immediately. When SSA finally caught up, they sent an overpayment notice for about $8,000. I was terrified, but they were actually pretty reasonable. They let me return it over 12 months with no interest since I had documented proof I'd been trying to report the death for months. The agent even apologized for their system failures. One tip: if you can get to your local office right when they open (usually 9 AM), you'll avoid the worst of the crowds. Bring multiple copies of everything. Good luck, and I'm sorry for your loss.
This is really helpful advice! I'm definitely going to try the early morning visit strategy - I hadn't thought of timing it that way. It's such a relief to hear that they were understanding about the payment plan when you had documentation. I've been keeping notes of our calls but I should probably be more systematic about it like you suggested. Did you have to deal with any bank issues when you were setting aside the funds, or were they pretty cooperative once you explained the situation?
Chloe Zhang
have u tried turning it off and on again? 🤣 jk jk... but seriously, sometimes just closing the browser completely and reopening works wonders
0 coins
Aisha Ali
I've run into this exact same issue before! Another thing to try is checking if you're using any browser extensions that might be interfering with the page display. Ad blockers or privacy extensions sometimes hide buttons by mistake. You could also try using incognito/private browsing mode to see if the logout button shows up there.
0 coins