Do student loans really count as the student providing their own support? I thought since they're loans that need to be paid back later, they wouldn't count for the current tax year?

Yes, student loans absolutely count as support provided by the student for the current tax year, regardless of when they'll be repaid. The IRS looks at who paid the expenses during the tax year, not where the money originally came from. Even if your parents cosigned the loans, as long as you're legally obligated to pay them back, the tuition and expenses paid with those loan funds count as support you provided for yourself. The same applies to scholarship funds - those count as support you provided (not support from your parents), even though the money comes from a third party.

The IRS actually contacted you both about this? How long did it take for them to notice the duplicate dependency claim?

It happened pretty fast! We both filed in February, and by April we each got letters asking for documentation. The duplicate dependency claim triggered an automatic flag in their system. The IRS actually put both of our refunds on hold until the issue was resolved. My parents had to pay back the extra refund they received from claiming me plus a small penalty. The whole process took about 3 months to resolve completely. Definitely not something you want to deal with during finals or job hunting!

Thanks for this! Definitely individual coverage in my case. So basically I just need to override TurboTax and report the full $200.08 as an excess contribution withdrawal, right? Did you have any issues with the IRS after filing that way?

Yes, exactly - override TurboTax and report the full $200.08 as an excess contribution withdrawal on line 13 of Form 8889. I had zero issues with the IRS after filing that way. The key is that you've already withdrawn the excess amount, which is the most important step. The reporting just needs to match what actually happened. The IRS receives Form 5498-SA directly from your HSA custodian, so they'll already know the actual contribution amount. Your tax return just needs to match that reality. I was worried too, but everything processed normally and I received my refund without any questions.

Did you need to file any extra forms with the HSA provider after withdrawing the excess? My HSA bank is telling me I need to specifically request a "return of excess contributions" rather than just a regular withdrawal.

Thank you for bringing this up! I actually do have student loans, so that's really helpful to know. Do you know roughly what income level the student loan interest deduction starts to phase out? And would HSA contributions have the same effect of lowering my AGI?

The student loan interest deduction starts phasing out at $75,000 for single filers and $155,000 for married filing jointly in 2024. Since you mentioned making $72,000, you're right at the edge where increasing retirement contributions could make a big difference. And yes, HSA contributions absolutely lower your AGI in the same way 401k contributions do! Both HSA and traditional 401k contributions are pre-tax and reduce your adjusted gross income. This can help you qualify for credits and deductions that have income limitations. In your case, both strategies would work together to potentially keep you fully eligible for the student loan interest deduction.

Generally: HSA first if you have matching funds for it (rare), then 401k up to employer match, then max HSA, then back to 401k. HSA has better tax advantages than 401k since withdrawals for medical expenses are tax-free (401k withdrawals are always taxed as income).

Did your sister mention anything about whether this affects how quickly we'll get our refunds once Feb 15th hits? Like if we're already in the system, do we get processed faster?

My sister says early filers definitely get processed faster once the Feb 15th date passes. The IRS essentially creates a queue of all the PATH Act returns (ones with EIC/CTC), and they process them in roughly the order received once that date hits. So being already in the system and "accepted" means you're at the front of that line. She also mentioned that most people with straightforward returns who file electronically and choose direct deposit usually see their refunds within 7-10 days after Feb 15th if they filed in January. So you could potentially see your money by Feb 22-25th.

That's totally normal this time of year. Mine was accepted on 1/15 and shows the same thing. It won't update to "Refund Approved" until after they can actually process the EIC/CTC returns after Feb 15th. It's frustrating, but at least we know they have it!

Can you deduct a home office if you're only doing this 1099 work part time? I use my spare bedroom for my freelance design work but it's not my main job.

Yes, you can still claim a home office deduction for part-time self-employment work. The key requirement is that the space must be used "regularly and exclusively" for your business activities. If your spare bedroom is used solely for your freelance design work and not for other purposes, you can deduct it. You have two options: the simplified method (currently $5 per square foot up to 300 sq ft) or the regular method where you calculate the actual expenses based on the percentage of your home used for business.

Would that be better than just using a Roth IRA? I thought those had better long-term tax benefits.