


Ask the community...
Don't forget to check if your state treats Roth distributions the same way as federal. I learned this the hard way. The feds didn't tax my Roth contribution withdrawal, but my state has different rules and I got hit with state taxes I wasn't expecting.
I didn't even think about state tax implications! Which state are you in that taxes Roth contribution withdrawals differently?
I'm in Massachusetts. They generally follow federal rules for retirement accounts, but they have some weird exceptions. For example, they don't recognize Roth 401(k)s the same way the feds do. California and New Jersey have some unique rules too. It's worth checking your specific state's tax department website or talking to someone who understands your state's rules. Each state can be different when it comes to retirement account taxation.
Has anyone tried just calling Schwab directly about this? My sister had a similar situation and they actually corrected the 1099-R coding after she explained it was a return of contribution.
One thing to remember when reporting foreign stock sales: you might need to convert both your purchase price AND sale price to USD if the transactions were in another currency. For the purchase, use the exchange rate from when you bought the shares. For the sale, use the exchange rate from when you sold them. This can actually work in your favor or against you tax-wise because you might have currency gains/losses in addition to the stock performance itself.
That's a really good point! But where do you find the official exchange rates to use? Is there an IRS approved source?
The IRS doesn't specify one official source for currency exchange rates, but they generally accept rates from major financial institutions or government sources. I typically use the Treasury Department's rates at https://fiscaldata.treasury.gov/datasets/treasury-reporting-rates-exchange/ or sometimes the Federal Reserve rates. You can also use rates from major financial publications like Bloomberg or the Wall Street Journal. Just be consistent in which source you use for all your calculations and keep documentation of where you got the rates in case of questions later.
Has anyone actually had the IRS question their manually entered stock transactions? I'm in a similar boat with some Singapore stocks not showing on my 1099-B and wondering how detailed I need to be with my documentation.
I had an IRS inquiry about manually entered stock sales a couple years ago. They just asked me to provide the purchase and sale confirmations to verify the cost basis and proceeds I'd reported. Wasn't a big deal since I had kept good records. They accepted everything without adjustments once I provided the documentation.
One thing nobody's mentioned is that if your foreign corporation is in a country considered a "low-tax jurisdiction" you might be dealing with GILTI (Global Intangible Low-Taxed Income) rules. This was part of the 2017 tax law changes and it basically forces US shareholders of certain foreign corporations to include some income on their US returns regardless of whether dividends were paid. If Thailand's corporate tax rate is lower than 90% of the US rate (which it likely is), some of your company's income could be considered GILTI and taxable to you even if you don't take dividends. It's another layer of complexity beyond just dividend reporting.
Wait, are you saying I might have to pay US taxes on money I haven't even taken out of my company as dividends yet? That sounds terrifying. How do I figure out if GILTI applies to my Thai company?
Yes, that's exactly what GILTI can do in certain situations. It was designed to prevent US taxpayers from indefinitely deferring US tax by keeping profits in foreign corporations. The calculation is complex, but essentially if your Thai company's income exceeds a certain return on its tangible assets, the excess could be considered GILTI and taxable to you personally even if the money stays in the company. To determine if GILTI applies, you'll need to look at your company's income, the value of its tangible depreciable business property, and Thailand's corporate tax rates. This is definitely an area where professional help is valuable. Form 8992 is used to report GILTI. You might be able to reduce the impact through something called the "high-tax exception" if Thailand's corporate tax rate is high enough, or through the Section 962 election that someone mentioned earlier. Both strategies can potentially reduce the tax impact of GILTI.
Has anyone dealt with the Transition Tax (Section 965) that hit a lot of us expat business owners a few years ago? I'm wondering if that's still something to worry about with foreign dividends or if that was a one-time hit?
The Transition Tax was a one-time tax on accumulated foreign earnings as part of the 2017 tax reform. If you've already dealt with that (or started your business after that), you shouldn't have to worry about it again. Now we just have to deal with GILTI every year instead! :-/
Has anyone tried just using a different browser? Sometimes these form issues are browser-specific. I had problems with Free File Fillable Forms in Chrome, but when I switched to Firefox everything worked fine, including the Schedule C vehicle section.
I haven't tried different browsers yet, that's a good suggestion. I've been using Chrome this whole time. Did you have this specific issue with the vehicle info disappearing and Firefox fixed it? Or was it a different problem?
I had almost the exact same issue - the vehicle information would disappear whenever I navigated away from Schedule C. Switching to Firefox completely resolved it for me. I think it might have something to do with how different browsers handle the form's JavaScript. Make sure you clear your cache and cookies before trying in the new browser. Also, when entering the vehicle info in Firefox, I made sure to click the specific "Save" button in that section before moving to any other part of the form.
FYI - If you call the Free File Fillable Forms support line at 866-829-2546, there's a recorded message specifically addressing the Schedule C vehicle information bug. They're aware of it but don't have a fix yet. The recommended workaround is attaching a statement with your vehicle information. Just create a simple document listing: - Vehicle make/model/year - Date placed in service - Business miles driven - Total miles driven - Whether you have evidence to support the deduction - Whether the evidence is written Apparently, they've communicated this issue to the IRS so returns with attached statements instead of filled-in vehicle sections should be processed normally.
This is really helpful info! Do you know if there are any other sections of the Free File Fillable Forms that have known bugs this year? I'm about to start my taxes and wondering if I should just use different software entirely.
Everett Tutum
You might want to check if you need to be designated as a representative payee for your grandmother. If she's receiving SSI, there are specific rules about who can manage those benefits on someone else's behalf. It's not just a tax issue but could be a Social Security compliance issue as well.
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
ā¢Thanks for bringing this up - I had no idea there might be specific rules for managing her SSI benefits. Her mind is still sharp, she just has physical limitations that make it hard for her to get around and handle paperwork. Does that matter for the representative payee requirement?
0 coins
Everett Tutum
ā¢If your grandmother is mentally capable of managing her benefits but just needs physical help, then you probably don't need to be a formal representative payee. The representative payee program is primarily designed for beneficiaries who can't manage their funds due to mental impairments. Since she's mentally capable and is voluntarily sending you the money to help manage her finances, this is more of an informal family arrangement. Still, it might be worth documenting this arrangement with a simple letter that you both sign, stating she's authorizing you to help manage her finances. This isn't required by law, but can be helpful documentation to have if questions ever arise.
0 coins
Sunny Wang
Have you considered setting up a joint bank account instead? That's what I did with my mom, and it makes everything much cleaner for tax purposes. Then you can pay her bills directly from that account instead of transferring money between accounts.
0 coins
Hugh Intensity
ā¢Be careful with joint accounts! If your grandmother ever needs to apply for Medicaid for long-term care, a joint account could be considered her asset AND your asset, which can complicate eligibility. This happened to my aunt and it was a mess to untangle.
0 coins