


Ask the community...
This is such a timely question! I actually work as a tax preparer and see this situation more often now with all the social media giveaways. The key distinction everyone's touching on is whether it's truly a "gift" versus compensation for services. The IRS has pretty strict criteria for what qualifies as a gift - it has to be made out of "detached and disinterested generosity" with no expectation of benefit to the giver. The moment you appear in a video, even briefly, you're providing promotional value to the creator, which disqualifies it from being a gift. One thing I'd add that I haven't seen mentioned - if you win a large amount (like $100k), you might want to consider making quarterly estimated tax payments instead of waiting until next year's filing. The IRS can charge underpayment penalties if you owe more than $1,000 when you file, especially on a large windfall like that. Also, state taxes vary widely on prize winnings - some states don't tax them at all, others treat them as regular income. Definitely worth checking your state's specific rules too!
This is really helpful information! I had no idea about the quarterly payment thing. Quick question - when you say "underpayment penalties," about how much are we talking? Like if someone wins $50k and doesn't make quarterly payments, what kind of penalty would they face when filing? I'm asking because I entered a bunch of giveaways recently and want to be prepared just in case I actually win something big.
@Mia Green The underpayment penalty rate changes annually but it s'currently around 8% it (was 7% for 2023 .)The penalty is calculated on the amount you underpaid for each quarter you missed. So for a $50k prize win, you d'owe roughly $12-15k in federal taxes depending on your bracket. If you didn t'make any quarterly payments and owed more than $1,000 when filing, you could face penalties of several hundred to over a thousand dollars depending on when during the year you won. The good news is there are safe harbor rules - if you pay at least 90% of the current year s'tax liability OR 100% of last year s'total tax 110% (if your prior year AGI was over $150k ,)you can avoid penalties even if you underpay on the prize winnings specifically. My advice if you win big: set aside 25-30% immediately, and consider making an estimated payment for the quarter you won. Better to be safe than sorry with the IRS!
One thing I haven't seen mentioned is what happens if you're under 18 when you win. My 16-year-old cousin won $8,000 from a TikTok challenge last year and we had no idea how to handle it tax-wise since minors usually don't file their own returns. Turns out that prize winnings are still taxable income for minors, and if it's over the standard deduction threshold, they need to file their own return (or their parents can include it on theirs in some cases). The creator actually required a parent to sign all the paperwork before releasing the money, which was smart on their part. Also learned that minors can't enter into legal contracts in most states, so technically a lot of these giveaways might not even be legally binding if the winner is under 18. But most creators just require parental consent to avoid issues. Just something to keep in mind for anyone with kids who might win these things!
This is such an important point that people don't think about! I'm actually curious - if a minor wins a large prize like this, are the parents responsible for setting aside money for taxes or does that responsibility fall on the minor themselves? Like if your cousin spent all $8,000 before tax time, who would the IRS come after for the tax bill? Also, do the parents' tax brackets affect how much tax the minor owes on prize winnings, or is it calculated separately?
I experienced this same frustrating situation two years ago and ended up learning a lot about how the IRS direct deposit system works. One thing that helped me was checking my bank account online to see if there were any failed deposit attempts. Sometimes banks will show a record of rejected deposits even if the IRS doesn't clearly communicate this. In my case, it turned out my credit union had updated their routing number for electronic deposits but hadn't properly notified account holders. The old routing number I used still worked for other transactions but caused issues with the IRS system specifically. If you haven't already, I'd suggest calling your bank to confirm they haven't made any recent changes to routing numbers or account processing that might affect government deposits. Sometimes these changes happen behind the scenes and customers aren't always notified immediately. Also worth noting - once you receive the paper check, you can usually deposit it via mobile deposit if your bank offers that service, which can speed up access to the funds compared to waiting in line at a branch.
That's a really good point about checking with your bank for routing number changes! I never would have thought of that. My bank actually did merge with another institution about 8 months ago, and while they said our account numbers would stay the same, they might have changed backend processing systems that could affect government deposits specifically. I'll definitely call them tomorrow to ask about any changes to their electronic deposit processing. And thanks for the tip about mobile deposit for the paper check - I completely forgot my bank offers that feature. That would definitely be faster than driving to a branch and waiting in line. It's so frustrating that the IRS "Where's My Refund" tool doesn't give you any of these specific details about WHY the deposit method changed. All these different scenarios people have shared show there are so many possible causes, but the IRS just says "your refund will be mailed" with zero explanation.
I'm dealing with this exact same issue right now! Filed in early March with direct deposit selected, and just like you, I've been getting DD refunds for years without any problems. Checked WMR yesterday and it now shows "refund will be mailed" with absolutely no explanation. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly eye-opening - I had no idea there were so many different reasons this could happen. The bank merger issue that several people mentioned really caught my attention because my bank was actually acquired by a larger institution last fall, though they assured us nothing would change with our accounts. What's really frustrating is that the IRS systems clearly know WHY they switched it to a paper check (whether it's a bank verification issue, processing error, etc.) but they just don't share that information through the WMR tool. We're left guessing and trying to troubleshoot something when they already have the answer. I'm definitely going to try some of these suggestions - checking my tax transcript for adjustment codes, calling my bank about any backend changes to their deposit processing, and setting up Informed Delivery. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences and solutions!
I'm going through the exact same thing and it's so reassuring to know I'm not alone! Filed in February with direct deposit and have been using the same bank account for refunds for over 5 years without any issues. Just checked yesterday and boom - "your refund will be mailed" with zero explanation. After reading all these responses, I'm starting to think it might be related to my bank too. They didn't merge, but they did send out notices about "system upgrades" a few months ago. I didn't think much of it at the time, but now I'm wondering if those upgrades affected how they handle government deposits. It's absolutely maddening that the IRS can't just include a simple reason code or explanation with the status change. Like "switched to paper check due to bank verification issue" or "switched due to processing adjustment" - something, anything! Instead we're all here playing detective trying to figure out what went wrong. I'm definitely calling my bank first thing Monday morning to ask about any changes to their electronic deposit systems. Thanks for starting this thread - at least now I have a game plan instead of just stressing about it!
I went through a very similar situation with my adult disabled sister a few years ago. The SSA denial was definitely frustrating, but as others have mentioned, the IRS uses completely different criteria for disability determination. One thing I'd add that really helped me was creating a detailed monthly expense log showing exactly what I was paying for versus what my parents contributed. This made the "more than half support" calculation crystal clear if I ever got audited. I tracked rent/utilities (allocated based on household size), groceries, medical expenses, transportation, clothing - everything. Also, make sure to get multiple medical opinions documented if possible. I had my sister's primary care doctor, neurologist, and pain management specialist all write letters specifically addressing her inability to work according to the IRS definition. Having multiple medical professionals corroborate the same conclusion made me feel much more confident about the disability determination. The good news is that once you have the proper documentation, this becomes much more straightforward in future years. Keep digital copies of everything and create a filing system now - it'll save you so much stress later. Your brother is lucky to have someone looking out for him during such a difficult time.
This is such a helpful and comprehensive thread! I'm dealing with a similar situation with my adult son who has autism and intellectual disabilities. He was also denied SSDI initially, which was incredibly disheartening. One additional point I'd like to add - make sure you understand the difference between "totally and permanently disabled" for tax purposes versus just meeting the dependency tests. If your brother qualifies as totally and permanently disabled, you might be eligible for additional credits like the Credit for Other Dependents, which can be worth up to $500. Also, I found it really helpful to create a simple spreadsheet tracking all support expenses month by month. This way you can clearly demonstrate that you're providing more than 50% of his total support. Include things like: - Your share of rent/mortgage and utilities - Food expenses - Medical costs (including insurance premiums if you're covering him) - Transportation costs - Personal care items The IRS Publication 501 has some great worksheets for calculating support that really helped me organize everything. Don't let the SSA denial discourage you - the tax code recognizes that people can be unable to work even when SSA doesn't agree. Your brother is fortunate to have your support during this difficult time.
Thank you for mentioning the Credit for Other Dependents! I hadn't even thought about that possibility. Since my brother is over 17 and disabled, that $500 credit could definitely help offset some of the expenses I'm covering for him. Your spreadsheet idea is brilliant - I've been keeping receipts but not organizing them in a way that clearly shows the support calculation. I'm going to set that up this weekend so I have a clear month-by-month breakdown. One question about the "totally and permanently disabled" distinction - is that something his doctor needs to specifically state in their letter, or is it determined by the IRS based on the medical documentation? I want to make sure I'm asking his doctors for the right language when they write their assessments. It's really encouraging to hear from others who've successfully navigated this process despite the initial SSA denial. The support in this community has been incredibly helpful!
Lol everyone's making this way more complicated than it needs to be. It's $27 of interest - the tax on that is like nothing. I've missed small 1099s before and literally nothing happened. The IRS has bigger fish to fry than chasing down a few bucks. Just include it next year if it bothers you that much.
I totally understand the stress you're feeling - I went through something similar a couple years ago! The good news is that for such a small amount, you're not in any serious trouble. From a practical standpoint, you have three solid options: 1) File Form 1040-X to amend your return (the "by the book" approach), 2) Wait to see if the IRS sends you a CP2000 notice and just pay the small difference then, or 3) Call the IRS directly to ask what they recommend for your specific situation. For $27.50 in interest, you're looking at maybe $3-7 in additional tax depending on your bracket. Even if there's a small penalty, it would be minimal. The IRS matching systems do catch these things eventually, but they often have tolerance thresholds for tiny amounts. If you want peace of mind and closure on this issue, filing the amendment is probably your best bet. Most tax software can handle simple amendments electronically now, which makes it much easier than the old paper forms. Whatever you decide, don't lose sleep over it - this kind of thing happens all the time and the consequences for such a small amount are very manageable!
This is really helpful advice, thank you! I'm leaning toward just filing the amendment to get it over with. One quick question - if I do file the 1040-X, roughly how long does it typically take for the IRS to process it? I'd rather know what to expect timeline-wise so I'm not checking my mailbox every day wondering if they got it.
Oliver Brown
I've been through this exact situation and it's definitely frustrating! One thing that really helped me was getting organized early in the process. Here's what I wish I had known from the start: First, don't wait too long to address this with your employer. The closer we get to tax filing deadlines, the more stressed everyone gets. Send a clear, written request to your HR/payroll team explaining that you need a corrected W2 with your actual home address and correct state information. Second, while you're waiting for their response, start gathering your documentation now. I kept copies of my lease, utility bills, internet bills used for work, and any emails or contracts that establish my remote work arrangement. This documentation becomes crucial if you need to file Form 4852 or if there are ever questions about your work location. Third, check your paystubs to see what state taxes are being withheld. If they're withholding for the company's state instead of yours, that's the bigger issue that needs immediate attention. The address is annoying but the state tax withholding affects your actual tax liability. Finally, even if your company drags their feet on the correction, you can still file your taxes on time. Use your correct address on your tax forms regardless of what the W2 shows, and if needed, file Form 4852 with an explanation of the situation. The IRS sees this more often than you'd think with remote workers. Hope this helps - you've got this!
0 coins
Ethan Clark
β’This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I'm actually in a similar boat as the original poster and this step-by-step approach makes me feel much more confident about tackling this issue. One question - when you mention checking paystubs for state tax withholding, what exactly should I be looking for? I see various deductions but I'm honestly not sure which line items indicate state taxes versus other withholdings. Is there a specific abbreviation or code I should watch for? Also, did you end up having to file in multiple states when you went through this? I'm trying to get a sense of whether this complicates my tax filing significantly or if it's mostly just a matter of using the correct information regardless of what's on the W2. Really appreciate you sharing your experience - it's reassuring to know others have navigated this successfully!
0 coins
Jeremiah Brown
β’@f3e2e4708cad Great questions! On your paystub, look for lines that say something like "State Tax," "SIT" (State Income Tax), or abbreviations for specific states like "CA SIT" or "NY SIT." Some companies use different formats, but it's usually pretty clear once you know what to look for. If you see withholdings for a state where you don't actually live/work, that's your red flag. In my case, I did end up filing in two states initially - a resident return in my actual home state and a non-resident return in the company's state to get back the taxes they had incorrectly withheld. It sounds more complicated than it is though. Most tax software walks you through this process, and the non-resident filing was basically just to claim a refund of the money that shouldn't have been withheld in the first place. The key thing is that once I got everything straightened out with my employer for the following year, it became much simpler. So while it might be a bit more paperwork this year, getting it fixed now will save you headaches going forward!
0 coins
Aisha Khan
I went through almost this exact situation last year! My company also put their office address instead of my home address on my W2, and it caused me a lot of stress initially. Here's what I learned: The good news is that this is more common than you'd think with remote workers, especially at smaller companies that haven't fully adapted their payroll systems. The bad news is that it can definitely complicate your tax filing if not handled properly. First thing to do is check Box 15 on your W2 - that's where the state code should be. If it shows your company's state instead of your home state, that's the real problem you need to address immediately. The address itself is primarily for mailing purposes, but the state withholding information directly affects your tax obligations. I'd recommend reaching out to your HR/payroll department with a formal written request for a corrected W2 (W2-c). Be specific about what needs to be corrected - your address and potentially the state information. Keep a copy of this request for your records. While you're waiting for their response, start documenting your remote work situation. Keep your lease agreement, utility bills, and any emails or contracts that establish where you actually work. This documentation becomes important if you need to file Form 4852 or explain the situation later. Don't let this delay your tax filing though. If your company doesn't provide a correction in time, you can file using your correct information and explain the discrepancy. The IRS understands these situations are becoming more common with remote work arrangements.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
β’This is really reassuring to hear from someone who's been through the exact same situation! I'm definitely going to follow your advice about checking Box 15 first - I honestly hadn't thought to look at that specific field but it makes total sense that the state code would be more critical than just the address. Your point about keeping documentation is spot on too. I've been pretty casual about saving work-from-home related paperwork, but I can see how having that trail of evidence could be really important if questions come up later. Better to be over-prepared than scrambling to find documents after the fact. One quick follow-up question - when you submitted your formal written request to HR, did you give them a specific timeframe to respond? I'm wondering if I should mention the tax filing deadline in my request to add some urgency, or if that might come across as too pushy. I want to be professional but also make sure this gets resolved in time for me to file properly. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's making me feel much more confident about tackling this issue head-on rather than just hoping it resolves itself!
0 coins