Since you mentioned being a single parent on $40k income, I also want to make sure you know that even after they fix the 401k rollover issue, you should check if your daughter qualifies for the Pell Grant and other need-based aid. With your corrected income, she likely will qualify for significant federal aid beyond just loans. The school might also have their own institutional grants for students in your situation. Make sure to ask about ALL available aid options when you contact them about the professional judgment review.

Quick update - got my son's financial aid recalculated after our retirement rollover issue. Took about 3 weeks after submitting all the docs. His SAI went from $33k down to $8k which made a HUGE difference in his aid package! Don't give up hope - the schools really do understand this is a common problem with the FAFSA calculations.

One strategy to consider: if you're still able to contribute to an IRA, you could move some of your savings there before completing the FAFSA. For 2025, the IRA contribution limit for someone over 50 is $8,000 ($6,500 base + $1,500 catch-up). This would effectively shelter that amount from FAFSA consideration. Just make sure you're eligible to contribute based on any earned income requirements.

I want to thank everyone for their incredibly helpful responses. Just to summarize what I've learned: 1. My regular savings accounts DO count as assets for FAFSA, even though I use them for retirement 2. At age 62, I get an Asset Protection Allowance of about $15,500 3. Only about 5.6% of my remaining assets affect the SAI calculation 4. I should look into moving some money to an IRA if possible 5. My Social Security survivor benefits may help qualify my daughter for Pell Grants This community has been amazing - I was so stressed about this, and now I feel like I can approach the FAFSA with much more confidence.

Using the IRS Data Retrieval Tool definitely reduces your chances of being selected for verification, but selection can still happen randomly or if there are discrepancies in your application. About 18% of FAFSA filers get selected for verification, so it's not uncommon, but it's not something everyone experiences either. If you are selected, respond promptly with all requested documentation to avoid delays in your financial aid disbursement.

So just to be super clear: Negative SAI = Good, means I'll likely get max Pell Grant ($7,395 for full-time, right?), but I should still contact my specific school about their institutional aid process and be prepared for possible verification. Thanks everyone for the help! This has been so confusing to figure out on my own.

i think this is all so unfair!!! my kid studied sooo hard and got 12k in scholarships and then our EFC went up because of it???? like punishing kids for doing well. the whole system is rigged against middle class families who make too much for pell grants but not enough to actually pay these crazy tuition bills

Update from my advising experience this year: schools are DEFINITELY becoming more accommodating about outside scholarships. Several universities have announced they're implementing a "no loan" policy for families under certain income thresholds, and many are specifically addressing the sibling penalty in their institutional methodology. The landscape is changing rapidly in response to the FAFSA changes. Key tip: when you receive your financial aid packages, compare them side by side with your daughter's outside scholarships listed. Then email each financial aid office with a specific proposal for how you'd like them to integrate the scholarships. Be direct but courteous. Many will work with you if you're specific about what you're asking for.

i wish i could help but we're in the same boat... my daughter will be a senior next year too and i'm just starting to research all this FAFSA stuff. it seems so complicated! especially since my husband and i divorced 2 years ago and now i don't know which parent is supposed to fill everything out? does anyone know if it's the custodial parent or the one who claims the kid on taxes or what?

Thank you all for the helpful advice! I'm going to start organizing our 2023 tax documents this weekend and look into the FSA ID setup. One more question - my son is interested in some private colleges that might be out of our price range without significant aid. Is there any way to estimate what kind of aid he might get before we go through the whole application process? I don't want him to get his hopes up for schools we ultimately can't afford.